now playing
Stop Fearing Carbs: What Actually Matters for Metabolic Health | Dr. Dariush Mozaffarian
Episode 226, duration 1 hr 33 mins
Episode 226
Stop Fearing Carbs: What Actually Matters for Metabolic Health | Dr. Dariush Mozaffarian
What you choose to eat is the single most important decision you make every day—impacting your metabolic health, your family, the economy, and the future of our food supply.
In this episode, world-renowned cardiologist and nutrition expert Dr. Dariush Mozaffarian breaks down the "Food is Medicine" movement, cuts through dietary confusion (fats vs. carbs, food label marketing, and ultra-processed ingredients), and reveals how public demand, science, and policy can repair a broken food system.
If you have ever felt overwhelmed in the grocery aisle or wondered how to separate real nutrition science from industry marketing, this conversation provides a clear, practical roadmap.
What you choose to eat is the single most important decision you make every day—impacting your metabolic health, your family, the economy, and the future of our food supply.
In this episode, world-renowned cardiologist and nutrition expert Dr. Dariush Mozaffarian breaks down the “Food is Medicine” movement, cuts through dietary confusion (fats vs. carbs, food label marketing, and ultra-processed ingredients), and reveals how public demand, science, and policy can repair a broken food system.
If you have ever felt overwhelmed in the grocery aisle or wondered how to separate real nutrition science from industry marketing, this conversation provides a clear, practical roadmap.
Food Quality, Protein, and Policy: What Dr. Dariush Mozaffarian Wants You to Know
Fourteen out of 15 American adults have at least one diet-related condition. One in three teens has prediabetes. And we spend $5.5 trillion a year on healthcare, with poor nutrition the leading driver. That’s the backdrop for my conversation with Dr. Dariush Mozaffarian: cardiologist, Harvard-trained Read More...
Speaker 1 00:00
The human brain and body is not hardwired to like ultra processed food.
Speaker 2 00:04
We are at a point that people are sick and they are tired of being sick.
Speaker 1 00:08
The system is broken, right? We can’t blame the individual and say it’s just on you to go make good choices. Most of the major food brands were bought up by the big tobacco companies. This is really what explains not only the obesity epidemic, but but why people can’t keep their weight off because they’re focusing on quantity, not quality.
Speaker 2 00:27
We’re overfed, but we’re undernourished.
Speaker 1 00:29
Beyond nutrients, there’s something about modern food that’s making us sick, and so ultra processing is not about salt or sugar or other common nutrients. It’s about the processing. The conversation has changed, and we can actually potentially fix things if if we follow the evidence.
Speaker 2 00:53
Dr. Mosafarian, welcome to the show.
Speaker 1 00:54
So nice to be here. Thank you so much, Gabriel.
Speaker 2 00:56
I’ve been following your career for years, and I saw you recently. We were both at an event together, and you were talking about the new dietary guidelines, where we are now, where we’ve come from, and I think that my first question or thought is: Do you think there is hope for the American population?
Speaker 1 01:17
I actually am optimistic. I mean, on the one hand, we are just being crushed by by the food system. It’s crushing our health. It’s crushing our economy. It’s crushing the environment. It’s causing incredible disparities. And so, on the one hand, things look really bleak today. 14 out of 15 adults have one or more diet related condition. Really, really shocking. It’s the number one cause of of poor health and healthcare spending. We spend $5.5 trillion, trillion dollars on on healthcare, which is really just hurting families, hurting businesses, hurting the federal government. We’re depleting our soil and water and and air with the way we grow food. You know, so if you put those three things together, this is the biggest single challenge facing humankind. I mean, I would put it toe to toe with anything else that people say is a major challenge, and yet you know with all that doom and gloom, I’m actually optimistic. I feel like we have the science to to really move towards real solutions. We know the policies actually that that will make a difference, and some of them may surprise you. They’re maybe not the usual suspects, and most importantly, the public realizes that we just can’t keep going on like this. I think now today, people want food that’s that’s authentic, that’s nourishing, that’s good for them, that’s good for the earth, and so I think we’ve passed the tipping point. I’m hopeful we’ve passed the tipping point.
Speaker 2 02:28
You brought up, and your book also is called “Food is Medicine. Yeah, but on one hand, food is medicine, but it sounds like it’s also the poison. And and you said one other thing: the food systems. How at our sickest, do you think that there is a way out?
Speaker 1 02:46
Food is not only medicine, as you said; it can be bad medicine or good medicine. But food is also dignity and culture and taste and flavor and family. Food is so many other things, but it really is biologic information. I mean, every bite we eat has 1000s and 1000s, sometimes 10s of 1000s of molecules that interact with almost every tissue in the body, interact with our genes, with our gut bacteria. So food really is the single leading determinant of health for most people. And yet, you know, we’ve ignored it or oversimplified it, you know, for decades. And I talk about that in the book: how we how we got here, why we oversimplify nutrition so much, and why the cutting edge science is is having us realize the the true solutions. And so I think the combination of science and public attention and government action is kind of what got us into this mess in the 20th century for different goals. But now that we have that science and government attention and innovation going on, we can actually potentially fix things if if we follow the evidence,
Speaker 2 03:41
I’m also really hopeful. I think that we are at a point that people are sick and they are tired of being sick, and then we have to think. You know, I have two little kids, and a lot of people out there have families. You have a family. The next generation they need to be able to be stronger as it relates to your personal interests. And I, I, I’ve always thought this to be fascinating. You are Harvard-trained cardiologist.
Speaker 1 04:04
I got my PhD at Harvard. Yeah. Oh, your
Speaker 2 04:06
PhD. Yeah. So that’s the the public health.
Speaker 1 04:09
Yeah.
Speaker 2 04:09
Right. You were also former dean of the Friedman School at Tufts.
Speaker 1 04:13
That’s right. Yeah.
Speaker 2 04:14
You have this very unique intersection between clinical practice, cardiology, and nutrition, but it’s unusual.
Speaker 1 04:23
Well, it’s kind of crazy that it’s unusual, right? If we talk about how big of an issue this is, but I want to return to where you started with with your children. You know, I have three teenagers, and I think about them and their health. And I’ve told them growing up that you actually have you know a far less than 50% chance, far less than you know. Really, 20% chance, just statistically, of growing up healthy. Right? Kids today have a over 50% chance of developing type two diabetes in their lifetime, and almost 80% chance of developing overweight or obesity in their lifetime. Their chances of being healthy are are small. And also, you know, you mentioned most people are sick, and I think what’s what’s really. Become noticeable to me is really just just sad, and we have to think about is that most people have have grown up feeling sick from as a child, even in the womb, and they don’t even know they feel sick. I mean, when you or I or people who are fortunate to kind of understand these issues and be able to generally eat well, when we have an unhealthy meal because we’re at an airport or we’re somewhere and we don’t have access to good food, we feel sick for several hours afterward, right? And many people listening might know that feeling. Most Americans-that’s how they feel all the time. And so, imagine the mental health, the physical health challenges that that most people are facing.
Speaker 2 05:31
I’ve interfaced with you on multiple occasions, and what really has also struck me is you feel very passionate about this, and that doesn’t just come from in an ivory tower looking at data. There must have been some kind of driving factor as to why that matters so much.
Speaker 1 05:51
Well, you know, first in my training, right? You asked, you know, is it why it’s unusual that a that a cardiologist would have such an interest in nutrition? You know, I did 15 years of training after high school, right? So four years of premed, four years of medical school, three years of maternal medicine, four years of cardiology, and in that 15 years, you know, I barely learned anything about about nutrition, right? And so that was just the first thing that was shocking to me because I could see it. I could just see it every day when I saw patients and worked with patients how big of a deal this was to them.
Speaker 2 06:19
Physicians are trained in this way of, you know, exercise more, move more, eat less. But was there just a moment where you thought to yourself, “This is not right.
Speaker 1 06:30
There probably wasn’t one moment. It was a it was a steady build up. But but the real, I think, there was one point that I really remember quite well. It was around 2000. I was in the middle of my cardiology fellowship, and I realized by then that nutrition was fundamental to health, and yet it was missing from healthcare. Right, that single sentence that that you know our food is the top cause of poor health and missing in healthcare actually explains so much about the problems and and what we’re facing today. So I said I’ll read everything I can myself, and I’ll really try to become an expert myself. And so I scoured the literature, I read every paper I could find, and again, this is 26 years ago, and we’re at the height of the low-fat diet in 2000. Right, everything was low-fat, fat-free salad dressing and fat-free cookies and snackwells. Snackwells, you know, toppled Oreo as as the top-selling cookie in the United States after 100 years, and yet even in 2000, 26 years ago, the the science didn’t support a low-fat diet. The evidence really supported what we know now, which is to have a high-healthy-fat, minimally processed diet that’s kind of Mediterranean style or whatever traditional culture you know you may want to you want to point out. Many of them have have similarities, and so that was the second really big realization for me, Gabrielle. Is I said that you know nutrition is being ignored in health, and the science that we have that’s in hand isn’t being translated to the public, and so I resolved to not only advance the science and work on nutrition as the top way I could help, not just one patient at a time in the clinic, but 1000s or millions or billions at a time in policy, but also to be sure that the evidence we had is translated. I didn’t want to be an armchair academic, right? I wanted to really, really help change the world.
Speaker 2 08:03
And at that time, was it a lot of epidemiology versus, say, randomized control trials? Because I feel like only in the last 10 years, and please correct me, is that we’ve really gotten into better ways of doing medicine.
Speaker 1 08:19
Well, you know, really, there was a lot of epidemiology both ways, but but the study that really struck me was the Lyon Diet Heart Study, which was a study in the ’90s that took people in France with a recent heart attack and randomized them to a traditional low-fat, low-saturated fat diet. That was the recommendation. I mean, I would write cardiac diet. I mean, you know, your physician would write cardiac diet, and they would put them on these low-fat, low-saturated fat, low cholesterol diets in the hospital, and yet the Lyon trial compared that traditional diet to a high healthy fat Mediterranean style diet, and it showed dramatic reductions in heart attacks. Dramatic reductions, like 60% reductions in heart attacks among people on a Mediterranean diet, and we’ve since confirmed that with many other studies. But people just didn’t believe it. They said, “How is it possible? How could a diet, you know, change health so much? But that study really struck me, and in fact, in in my fellowship in cardiology, I proposed to do a Mediterranean diet style in the United States, and I actually had a foundation hear hear me talk about it and want to give me money to do the study. So I was I was like I was excited, and what was amazing is I was at a top you know, institution, one of the top medical centers in the country, and I couldn’t find a single senior physician to to be kind of the lead. Since I was a fellow in training, I needed somebody to be the lead. I looked across the whole institution and couldn’t find anyone that said they had experience or interest to be the lead, and so I couldn’t do the study. And so, you know, again, it’s just a microcosm of of how far away we are from what we should be doing for this largest problem facing the health of the world.
Speaker 2 09:46
It’s a really good point, and also the slow translation of science, which is arguably kind of where we’re at right now. Would would you say you’ve been involved in federal policy for? How long have you been involved in federal policy?
Speaker 1 10:02
Well, I really got interested in policy when, through my research, I started working with major organizations like the United Nations and the World Health Organization and the American Heart Association and and many others. And again, I realized that that the scientific solutions they were talking about were not grounded in in science. They were talking about things that would have incremental benefits, if any, and the things that really worked, they weren’t talking about. And so, a big part of the book is actually helping people see what we really need to do. But when I really went in deep in in policy was when I came to Tufts in 2014, and I learned about Jean Mayer, who founded our school. And I didn’t really know his history. Jean Mayer was a brilliant French nutrition scientist who, when he was in university in France, and France was invaded by the Nazis, he signed up for the war. He fought in the Battle of Dunkirk. He was captured. He shot a guard. He escaped. He went into the French underground. He came to the United States, joined the Free French forces, shipped out across the Atlantic. There was a storm. He turned back, and they came to a port in Canada, in Nova Scotia. He called his girlfriend in Boston. He said, “I’m in port for 24 hours. Let’s get married. She came up. They they got married. He didn’t see her for four years. Again, he won multiple medals of valor. Came back and married, lived with her, you know, as as his wife for the rest of his life. I say all this because he ended up becoming, you know, a prominent nutrition scientist. And this was clearly a guy who was incredibly smart, but knew you had to pair intelligence with action. Right,
Speaker 2 11:26
I love that
Speaker 1 11:26
he was not a guy who sat back. And so, one of the things he did, I learned before he became president of Tufts and founded our school, is he, with Nixon, founded a conference, the White House conference on on food, nutrition, health in 1969, that really, you know, changed all of our federal food policy around hunger. Dramatically changed it. It expanded SNAP, which was food stamps at the time. It created WIC, which is the program that 40% of babies in the United States receive. It created school breakfast. It dramatically expanded school lunch. And so, really, all of our policies that we kind of think about major policies came out of this conference, and yet while this conference was incredibly important, when I became dean, that conference was in the ’60s. There had been no national kind of focus on food and nutrition and health since that 1960s conference, and so I got very interested in that. And right away in 2014, started to try to see if we could have a second conference happen in the United States,
Speaker 2 12:21
and were you successful?
Speaker 1 12:22
Well, so first we went to the Obama administration. This was the last two years of the administration, and there was quite a bit of interest from the First Lady at that time, Michelle Obama, as you can imagine. And we spoke with her, and we spoke with the Domestic Policy Council and others in the White House. And I would say maybe we got about two thirds of the way to a yes, but it was the last two years, and and the President Obama at that time thought this was maybe not his major focus. He wanted to focus on the economy and on jobs, and we tried to explain that food is really central to the economy and jobs because of all these issues. But you know we weren’t successful. And then the next president was the first term of President Trump, and we pivoted because his presidency was unpredictable at that time. We we pivoted to focus on Congress and really helped generate a lot of attention in Congress on food as medicine and found some great allies there, like Congressman Jim McGovern, who’s in Massachusetts, or Senator Cory Booker in New Jersey, and others. Bipartisan support, though. And then when President Biden was was nominated as a Democrat, we reached out to his team and said, you know, this is really the time to focus on nutrition. And through our advocacy and and many friends as well, we were able to have President Biden hold a second conference. And so in 2022, there was the second White House conference over 50 years after the first one, and it was a really important conference. It really brought together healthcare and food and other health organizations to really start talking about this issue, and also all the agencies. Right, food is in every agency. It’s in you know USDA, education, the VA, the Department of Defense, and so really that started the momentum towards the federal government and healthcare and the food system thinking about how we need to change things, and of course, now with the Make America Healthier again movement and the Trump administration, I think it’s the only thing that was a priority for the Biden administration that sort of continued into the Trump administration. Everything else has been, you know, dismantled or overturned, but not not food and not not food as medicine. So I think the combination of that that Biden administration attention and the Trump administration attention shows that this is not a partisan issue, and has greatly accelerated it. And to the credit of the Maha movement, it’s taken something that was happening in industry and healthcare and government, and has made it a very public issue.
Speaker 2 14:35
I really appreciate you bringing up your experience in federal policy and taking us through as the administrations change, because health is not-it doesn’t have a party. Health is available and should be available for everybody. And one of the things I really appreciate about you is the history. You bring a lot of history, and seeing these things change. You said that. There is the healthcare system, and then there are the agencies. The agencies, USDA, veterans, and then there is, from what I understand, also industry. Is there another sector?
Speaker 1 15:13
I think those are the three big ones that that relate to to food, and of course, science. Right, we need to have science and evidence, and and the food sector is quite broad, so people think of immediately when they think of food, especially unhealthy food, they think of the big, you know, food manufacturers. But we have to remember that that food is is many, many other players, from the farms to the supply chains to all the restaurants and all the cafes and entertainment venues. The food sector is quite large.
Speaker 2 15:38
And the reason I bring this up is because you know if we were sitting here, and I know that if I was an outside observer, I’d be like, I don’t understand what is so difficult. You guys had the food dye pyramid; that was a total screw up. Fix that, and then just go execute, right? In in my mind, but it’s much more complicated, right? In terms of what is sold at the grocery store, what is available at Wic Snap? It’s again, I’m an outsider from the industry component, it seems very complicated and integrated.
Speaker 1 16:04
It isn’t. It’s not right. There actually are a few solutions, pretty simple solutions that would transform and really restore the right direction of this Titanic that is that is the food system and about to crash into an iceberg. I think the challenge is that the current solutions that people think about tend to be very small solutions that wouldn’t make a big difference. So they talk about the dietary guidelines, or even school meals, or labeling, or the farm subsidies. You know, and all those things are important, and we need to to address them. But I think first and foremost, we have to understand how we got here. Why do we have the food system we do today? And that’s where my book starts. And and most accounts of the food system today sort of start around 1980 with the rise of big multinational food corporations and kind of the industrialization of food and lobbying and negative aspects of industry, and again those things are true. I mean, food industry has done a lot of bad things, but that’s not really where it started, right? We didn’t the food industry didn’t set out to make us sick, right? That and so you have to kind of kind of go back. Which is an
Speaker 2 17:03
important statement.
Speaker 1 17:04
Yes,
Speaker 2 17:04
I’m sure that you hear that food industry wanted to make us sick.
Speaker 1 17:09
Pharma wants to make about tons of money. This is doctors don’t care. They want to make money too. Yeah,
Speaker 2 17:13
right. And I would argue that that’s not true. Are you also of the belief that that’s not entirely true? Yeah,
Speaker 1 17:20
I mean, most of the reasons we’re here is very purposeful actions by government and business leaders and scientists who had actually the best interests of humanity at heart and and fixed problems that were the problems of the day. And so I talk about that in the in the first chapters of the book. You know, the three big trends of the 20th century were vitamins, the discovery of vitamins, a quadrupling of the world population in 100 years that led to great great fears of of food shortages and famine and finally the the rise of kind of industrial processing and so those three things thinking about vitamins thinking about calories and then thinking about how to process foods for stability and shelf life and price and all those things basically led to the modern food system, and we have to give credit. Those innovations actually made a big difference in the 1920s. Diet-related diseases were not the big the big thing. The big thing was vitamin deficiencies. You had diseases like scurvy, you know, overseas. You had pellagra, which is niacin deficiency, which killed 100,000 people in the United States in the 20s, and maybe 3 million people had it. And when it happened in the 1920s, people thought it was an infectious disease. They didn’t even know what it was because niacin hadn’t been discovered. And so, when the vitamins were discovered, and the major vitamins, and when the Green Revolution happened to create kind of modern industrialization of crops to supply enough calories for the world, those were big successes. We essentially eliminated very common vitamin deficiency diseases that were affecting you know millions and millions of people in the United States and around the world. Diseases that we don’t even hear about anymore, right? Although some of them, like rickets or vitamin D deficiency, is coming back. Most of them are gone. And then we also dealt with calories, the Green Revolution with kind of the industrialization of crops, with Norman Borlaug, who won the the Peace Prize for his work, probably saved a billion people from starving in the last century, and so we have to start with that that that we created this kind of if you look at the Walmart aisle of cereals, which is all starchy, inexpensive products that last forever on the shelf, they cost pennies, and they’re fortified with vitamins, right? Those were intentional things to solve the problems of the 20th century. But what we didn’t realize is that the stripping away of the complexity of food, the loss of biodiversity in our crops, the processing of food would lead to this explosion of diet-related disease. And and there was a nefarious component as well. And so, at one point in the 1970s and 1980s, most of the major food brands were bought up by the big tobacco companies. You know, you had Philip Morris and R.J. Reynolds buy up almost every major brand you can think of. They started applying their same brain science and addiction science and marketing science that they had used for tobacco to food, and so that’s when things really, really. Went dark, but until then, until that happened, really, this was three things coming together: it was science, industry, industry innovation in particular, and government all coming together around common goals. And so I’m excited because we can do that again if we get the right science and we get government interested to support and we get private sector innovation. All these changes that I’m talking about happened from like 1970 to 1980, 1990. It was 20 years we transformed the global food system, and so I really believe we can do it again in just 20 years and really solve all these, all these, all these problems.
Speaker 2 20:34
In the 80s, early 90s, the obesity boom hit. What do you think the major cause was
Speaker 1 20:42
well. The first thing I’m going to say is I don’t know, and it’s shocking. And it’s shocking that I don’t know, right? I’ve been studying this my whole career, and actually, the causes of the obesity epidemic are not clear, right? I want to say that again. We don’t understand the causes of the greatest change in human health ever seen in the history of humankind. But
Speaker 2 21:00
people will say it’s when processed foods really were beginning to really be consumed, and carbohydrate intake was high. Right there’s a lot of statements that are made. Is is that fair to say?
Speaker 1 21:12
Yeah, and I and I and I really review this in detail in in in a chapter in the book on obesity. And so I think the first thing to say, which is clear, is that the obesity epidemic was very new and happened very quickly, and so it really was around the late 1980s that it sort of took off. And so that’s important because the 1950s and 1960s and 1970s were not this golden age of lifestyle, right? Where everybody was eating healthy food and going to yoga and doing all these other things, right? I’m pretty sure they were smoking. So we really have to understand what happened in the late 1980s? Probably the biggest changes were the ultra processing of food, with a shift away from kind of structurally intact ingredients to molecularly disassembled food. We actually stopped making bread that was basically you know wheat ground up and turned into bread, which is what an artisanal bakery would do now, and turned it into something like you know Wonder Bread or some of these other products became became very very popular. All the cereal, all the energy bars, everything else. That industrialization of food led to probably the biggest macronutrient change was a rise in carbohydrates. That’s the biggest change, and not sugars. Sugar actually hasn’t changed that much from 1950 to now, surprisingly,
Speaker 2 22:21
and protein intake really hasn’t. Protein’s been
Speaker 1 22:24
flat, yeah, and and fat intake’s been relatively flat. It’s gone down a little bit, but really, what rose is was refined grains, so wheat starch, rice starch, potato starch, and corn starch. That exploded again, mostly molecularly disassembled, ultra processed.
Speaker 2 22:37
Do you think that that plays a role, no longer having that food matrix?
Speaker 1 22:41
Absolutely. So we can, you know, we can talk about ultra processed foods. I think there’s several several issues, but that was a major change. And I think the other changes were the addition of additives, which I used to think weren’t a big deal, but we now realize our obesogens and endocrine disruptors and alter neurodevelopment and and alter our microbiome. So all the additives. I was just covering carrageen. Caragene is an additive from algae, and for individuals that have alpha gal, alpha gal syndrome, which is carried by the lone star tick, that is a trigger for people. Yeah, so carrageen is actually from you know a natural original source, and there are some studies that it could be beneficial in some people, but we don’t know what it could do in everyone. And I think other additives like artificial sweeteners are particularly problematic.
Speaker 2 23:27
Even though people would argue, right? People would say they’re not going to affect humans at the doses that they’re consuming, right? Yeah.
Speaker 1 23:35
So I used to think they weren’t a big deal, but studies in the last five years have really come out and shown that’s not true. There have been randomized trials in people showing that some non-caloric sweeteners actually alter the microbiome and worsen glucose tolerance. Is there one in particular?
Speaker 1 23:50
Well, the ones that have been most implicated are sort of the older ones like sucralose and aspartame. But even some of the newer ones like stevia and erythritol have been shown to at least not be innocuous. They have effects on platelets, or they have effects on the microbiome, and so the way I look at that whole class of additives, as well as common emulsifiers and stabilizers and colors, is that we’re not 100% sure they’re harmful, but we’re not 100% sure they’re safe. And so why are we putting something in food when we’re so sick that we’re not 100% sure that evidence
Speaker 2 24:19
doesn’t necessarily mean that they are innocuous. Yeah,
Speaker 1 24:23
I think the really amazing thing to be about obesity, Gabrielle, is that the common concept that we’re eating more and we’re gluttonous and we’re overeating and that ultra-processed foods are making us overeat and that we’re exercising less isn’t actually supported by the evidence. And so that’s kind of wild and crazy. Wait,
Speaker 2 24:39
tell me more. If
Speaker 1 24:40
you go back again to the onset of the obesity epidemic, late 1980 s, and you see what happened to trends in calories and physical activity, from roughly the 1970 s to 2000, calories did slowly rise, and so overall, over that 20 or 30 years, they rose by about 300 calories per person per day over that time period, which is more than enough to explain the obesity epidemic. Some would argue, well, we were also gaining weight, and so we had to eat more to maintain that weight. So, what’s the chicken and what’s the egg? But nonetheless, calories and body weight went up together until about 2000. What’s really striking, and and most people don’t realize, is that after 2000, calorie intake at the population level in the United States has actually gotten flat, or even gone down, and physical activity by multiple measures has gone up. There’s more people running, more people in the gym, more people done yoga
Speaker 2 25:27
don’t don’t realize that
Speaker 1 25:28
people are exercising more. We’re still a lot of sedentary people. We’re not where we should be, but but we’re not worse than we were in 2000. And so, how is it possible if physical activity’s slowly gone up a little bit and calories have been flat or gone down since 2000, obesity has continued to rise, and so why is obesity rising when we’re eating the same and we’re exercising more? And so that’s really a fundamental question to understanding obesity.
Speaker 2 25:51
As I think about some of the the work that I’ve done, you know, when I was an undergrad with Don Layman, we look we did randomized control trials where we covered calories, so that both groups were isocaloric. One group had a food guide pyramid kind of set up, and then the other group had a higher protein intake, kind of what is reflected in the new current guidelines. And body composition improved. So if exercise was equal, the one that had calorie control exercise, their body composition improved, and I think that we see that in multiple randomized control trials. Is the quality of evidence different when we look at it at, say, a population level than if we look at it at a 12-week study?
Speaker 1 26:34
Well, there’s so many things we don’t know, right? And we’re just scratching the surface of it. And and one of the things that I think we need to do is dramatically increase our investment in nutrition science, and the National Institutes of Health, which is our country’s you know major organization, the world’s major organization to do research, you know spends a pittance on on true nutrition science, and that hasn’t changed in 40 years, even as diet-related diseases skyrocketed. So we really need a a food shot or you know moonshot, as you might call it, to really understand nutrition. The NIH is about $50 billion a year, and so we should spend at least 10% of that, 5 billion a year, 20% of that, 10 billion a year, to cover the top cause of poor health, which is nutrition. And so, until that happens, we’re going to have a lot of unanswered questions. But from the science that we have, I think what’s clear is that the overall long term, the quality of the diet trumps the quantity. What do I mean by that? You know, if you want to lose weight in the short term, over three months or six months, you can go on almost any diet you want and count your calories and wash your calories and reduce your portion sizes, and you’ll lose weight. That’s why any fad diet book sells because people will try it, and initially they’ll be successful. You could be on a paleo diet, a keto diet, a low carb diet, a low fat diet. You could be on a gummy bear diet, and you will lose weight for a few months. The
Speaker 2 27:50
data does support that any of those diets are reasonable
Speaker 1 27:52
to lose weight for a short
Speaker 3 27:54
period. Except maybe
Speaker 1 27:55
gummy bear, but yeah, yeah, not no. I think
Speaker 2 27:57
if calories are controlled, if
Speaker 1 27:58
calories are controlled, you will lose weight. Yeah, but long term, we are biological creatures, and so long term, the our biology shifts, our resting metabolic expenditure shifts, which has to do with things like thermogenesis, the generation of heat, our microbiome changes, the amount of calories our microbiome digests versus what we digest changes. There’s actually evidence that what you eat can actually affect the electron movement through the mitochondria that generates our energy. So think about like electrons from hydrogen atoms moving through the the Krebs cycle, which you know we we we learned about in medical school.
Speaker 2 28:33
I’m still trying to forget that.
Speaker 1 28:34
We really have to think about biology, and you know, big picture. While while a lot of the details need to be understood. The more ultra-processed a food is, the further it is away from nature. The less fiber it has, the less bioactives it has. All of those processes get thrown out of whack. And the more it’s closer to nature, and the more it’s it’s it’s full of fiber and healthy fats and other phytonutrients, the more those processes are nurtured and helped, and so over years, I think this is really what explains not only the obesity epidemic, but but why people can’t keep their weight off because they’re focusing on quantity, not quality.
Speaker 2 29:12
You bring up a point that I think is important to recognize: it’s very difficult to have randomized control trials that last 15 years. You know, when I think about body composition and sarcopenia, the decrease and change in body composition over one year is minuscule, but collectively over 20 now you or even 10 you you start to really see changes.
Speaker 1 29:34
And most studies of obesity and nutrition have looked at weight loss, and people have already failed their own weight loss effort, so it’s really the the end game, right? You’ve you’ve gained weight, you already have obesity, you’ve tried many things and failed them, so you enroll in this study. Whereas the cause of the obesity epidemic is actually slow weight gain, and so the average American gains about a pound per year, a pound per year, not a pound per month, a pound per year, which
Speaker 2 29:58
doesn’t sound like very much. It
Speaker 1 29:59
doesn’t, but. That’s what is the obesity epidemic, right? You graduate high school, you’re 18, and 20 years later, you’re 38. You weigh 20 more pounds, right? That’s the obesity epidemic. So, trying to understand what causes a pound of weight gain per year is almost impossible. And and I really again emphasize biology. A person might think, oh, I ate that, I overate it, or I ate this, and my weight was better, but when it’s a pound per year, people really struggle to understand. Let alone five pounds over five years, people really struggle to understand and don’t. I think actually have a good sense of what’s helping them or hurting hurting them in terms of long term weight control.
Speaker 2 30:34
Yeah, it’s very insidious. But the food matrix, meaning all of the compounds, for example, if someone eats a steak, it’s not just the B 12 and the zinc and the protein. There’s and serine, there’s creatine, there’s taurine, there’s a whole host of of other nutrients, and the same with plants. A whole bunch of phytonutrients and fiber, and the complexities of these are really important for human health. And then you know, as we think about the practicality of it, if cardiovascular disease has been the leading cause of death in the United States for nearly a century, the old way of thinking about it, which I guess from what I see, is people think about saturated fat and also obviously smoking and inactivity, but then the new guidelines have arrived, which you are a part of. But saturated fat at 10% or less of calories still exists. How do we reconcile the two? The the older evidence that maybe was unsupported to now.
Speaker 1 31:37
Well, so you know the way I look at it is we have two kind of streams of evidence. We have the kind of 1980s evidence, 1980s approach, which which was to take single nutrients and try to apply those single nutrients to disease conditions. And the reason we have that approach in 1980 is because that worked so well to address vitamins in the earlier decades. To understand you know scurvy, we have to identify that vitamin C was the issue and address vitamin C, but so when it came to heart disease, people took that same approach and they said, “Okay, we have to address heart disease. What’s the nutrient? And they picked saturated fat. But what we’ve learned since is that the science is much more complex. And so you know, when I started at Harvard as a young faculty member, I was on something called the K Award, which is an award from the National Institutes of Health to do research. and and the title and focus of my K award was what are the nutrients that are the best replacements for saturated fat? You know, I was believed in the saturated fat hypothesis because you know I I that’s what I had had learned, and I said is it mono unsaturated fats, protein, polyunsaturated fats, carb? And amazingly, in those few years of of my my research, I learned and I realized that saturated fat just isn’t a risk factor of heart disease to begin with.
Speaker 2 32:45
You tried to prove to yourself that it was right,
Speaker 1 32:48
and I started out with the opposite hypothesis.
Speaker 2 32:50
But how were you able to see it?
Speaker 1 32:52
Well, it’s it’s obvious actually. All the science is there right now.
Speaker 2 32:55
But you were able to see it. You were able to question your own beliefs that saturated fat wasn’t the primary issue yet? We still, you know, is it a stubbornness of an industry, or is it that we just are not keeping up with the science? How do we change our mind about things that we absolutely thought that we believed?
Speaker 1 33:13
So I’ve seen this for saturated fat. Every time there’s a major study that that shows that it’s really not a major risk factor, the community of believers slightly adjust their hypothesis to to meet the new science. Yes, saturated fat alone isn’t important. So yes, but saturated fat is important if you replace it for polyunsaturated fat, for example. Or while saturated fat in dairy maybe is not a big deal, but saturated fat in red meat is still a big deal, which actually could be true because the types of fat are actually different in dairy and red meat. But the the hypothesis just gets adjusted. At the same time, more and more people are peeled off of that kind of core belief. In my experience, you know, most people who who I think you know really cling to this outdated notion about saturated fat, they honestly believe it. You know they’re not trying to to do anything intentionally wrong, but either they don’t know the science that well because this isn’t their their their core thing that they do, or like I said, if they know the science well, they sort of find backdoors and and and kind of excuses. It’s complicated, so we can’t just say saturifat’s inert. We know it’s not inert, but the bottom line is, as a class, if you take all saturated fat from all food sources, there’s different types of saturated fat.
Speaker 2 34:26
Very important.
Speaker 1 34:27
There’s from the based on the chain length of saturated fat, like MCTs. MCTs are saturated fats that have metabolic benefits that are in dairy, for example. There’s different things in the food. You’ve talked about the food matrix. Dairy has very specific fats called sphingolipids and phospholipids that actually reduce cholesterol absorption in the gut.
Speaker 2 34:46
That was added in the new dietary guidelines for the first time in 45 years. High fat dairy, yeah, that that
Speaker 1 34:52
whole fat dairy is okay, which is totally evidence based. You know, science moves slowly, and this is just one idea that that hasn’t fallen away, but. I will say that that science changes. So in 1980, the guidelines recommended low total fat, low saturated fat, and low dietary cholesterol. In 2015, you know, 10 years ago, the guidelines quietly dropped the low fat and the low dietary cholesterol. Those were both dropped quietly. Nobody made a big deal about it because they didn’t want to say we were wrong. But by the way, I
Speaker 2 35:19
want to pause here because I’ve been in practice for 20 years, and over the last 10 years, that they drop the cholesterol, the dietary cholesterol component.
Speaker 1 35:28
People used to say eggs were bad and shrimp was bad.
Speaker 2 35:30
Would you believe that people still go to their doctor and they still hear that that someone will have high cholesterol and they will, you know, obviously take their blood work at their physician’s office, and the doctor will say, “Stop eating eggs and shrimp.
Speaker 1 35:44
That’s right,
Speaker 2 35:45
because of the cholesterol in
Speaker 1 35:46
it. Even though that was dropped, it was dropped, as I said, quietly. And so I really thought this was going to be the year, and in fact, I thought 2020 was going to be the year that saturated fat would also be dropped. And I was actually surprised that it wasn’t. And if you look at the Dietary Guidelines Advisory Committee, which was the independent scientists that were set
Speaker 2 36:03
up. This one or the last one?
Speaker 1 36:04
This one set up by the Biden administration, not the not the Trump administration. Scientists who were picked to review the evidence. They actually reviewed all the evidence for dairy, for example, and they found no evidence. No evidence in their conclusions that switching between whole fat dairy and low-fat dairy had any effect on heart disease, on diabetes, on obesity, on mortality, on any outcome they looked at, and yet they didn’t recommend in their science report to drop the focus on low-fat. So there is this disconnect between what people see and and and and their science. As you noted in the current guidelines, they say whole-fat dairy is okay with no added sugar.
Speaker 2 36:42
You’ve also published that there are some benefits to higher fat dairy that there’s a compound in there or not just one compound. Is there a failure to recognize that perhaps it could even be health promoting?
Speaker 1 36:55
Well, so I think dairy fat’s quite interesting, and and dairy food is complicated. And I think even more important than the fat content of the dairy is the type.
Speaker 2 37:02
I agree with that. And so
Speaker 1 37:03
butter is not milk, is not yogurt, is not cheese. They’re all different foods, actually. And among those, butter is probably the least beneficial. It may not be harmful. It may not be beneficial. I kind of put it as like a background neutral food. Butter has actually lost some of these beneficial sphingolipids and and other specialized fats. To make it, you throw those away as buttermilk. That’s what buttermilk is probably throwing away these really beneficial fats. Cheese and and milk and yogurt are interesting. Milk is pretty consistently linked to lower blood pressure and actually in trials lowers blood pressure and also lower risk of stroke, which goes along with that. So milk probably modestly reduces a risk of stroke and also helps with bones and height and bone strength. Yogurt is a fermented food, is linked to low risk of diabetes and less weight gain. And cheese actually is also a fermented food. It’s the top fermented food consumed in the United States. And cheese, interestingly, is not linked to weight gain. It’s not linked to heart disease, and it’s also linked to low risk of diabetes. And so all the research we’ve done has suggested that dairy fat is either neutral or modestly beneficial, not harmful, and so I don’t think there’s enough evidence yet to say you should have whole-fat dairy only. I think we need more science, but there’s definitely enough evidence to say that you can have whole-fat dairy instead of low-fat dairy. And so right now, I recommend to people to have whatever fat content you want, and more importantly, have a variety of types. And so have yogurt, have cheese, have milk, and especially don’t have it with with added sugar and additives. Now, the dietary guidelines retain this 10% saturated fat limit. People have said that’s contradictory to saying that whole fat dairy is okay. I think, I mean, I wasn’t there when the final guidelines were written, but I think probably that was done mostly so that organizations that might have come out against the dietary guidelines. Some of the big clinical societies and other things would have been very angry. So I kind of feel like it was an olive branch by USDA and HHS to those major clinical organizations. And so I think it was. I really think it should have been dropped. I think it’s a mistake to keep this 10% limit.
Speaker 2 38:57
We’ve had Tom Brenna on the show. We’ve had Heather Lighty on the show. We’ve had nearly everybody that was a part of the guidelines, except for maybe one person on the show, and they certainly mirror what you’re saying. And the complexities around saturated fat and just fats in general is really fascinating. Right now, we talk about different types of fiber, we talk about macronutrients. This is more of a hypothetical question. In my mind, I’m hoping that we are able to have very specific recommendations for amino acids. Again, this is just hopes and dreams. That say someone has high blood pressure and maybe they happen to be lower in arginine. Again, these are my hopes and dreams. Instead of watching Netflix, I’m I’m thinking about arginine. Do you think there’s a world where we become so sophisticated, where we know the saturated fat, the kinds of fats that are going to be, and in the amounts appropriate for that person, really personalized nutrition.
Speaker 1 39:53
It’s a beautiful question because I think the answer is is as as for many things in nutrition, yes and no. Right. On the one hand, I think what we’re learning is that it’s all pretty simple. Right. We just have to have foods as close as possible to their natural state. Not worry about fat. Actually, embrace fats and enjoy fats, especially fats from seafood and from plants. Really, the the major challenge we have is to avoid foods that that are rich in refined starches and sugars, and also to not eat foods that don’t spoil. Right. Because if food doesn’t spoil, foods are supposed to spoil. If a food can, if a if a piece of beef or turkey or chicken can sit in your refrigerator for weeks in a package, you know it’s probably not something you you want to eat. If something can sit on your shelf for a year, like pop tarts, I shouldn’t have eaten those. It’s probably not something you should be eating. So so on the one hand, it’s pretty simple, and and critically, we have to get to to policy changes to make that kind of natural diet easier and cheaper.
Speaker 2 40:47
Very challenging for
Speaker 1 40:48
everybody. But then on the flip side, as the science advances, we’re also learning about these incredible nutrients-not just amino acids and fatty acids and carbohydrates, but these 1000s and 1000s of polyphenols and other bioactives, which I think I think to me that’s the real future of nutrition. And so things that are in cocoa, things that are like like epicatechin and apples, or EGCG and green tea, or some of the powerful phenolics and blueberries, or nuts and seeds. These molecules we’ve evolved to eat these plants, and the plants nurture us so that we we are healthy and we travel around the savanna or the jungle and we spread their seeds and they nurture our microbiome, who’s symbiotically you know evolved with us over over 10s of 1000s of years, and so that’s I think one of the challenges of ultra processed foods that we stripped away these these nutrients because we don’t even measure them. They’re not in the package. No, I know they’re not regularly measured. They’re present at trace quantities. Yeah,
Speaker 2 41:44
and it’s also going to be really difficult because it’s probably the metabolomics of these. For example, say urolithin A. You eat a pomegranate and I eat a pomegranate. You might have the correct microbiome to then produce urolithin A, which is this postbiotic that helps with the mitochondria, and I might not. This is again. I’m hoping that we’ll get to this place. But in your book, you make recommendations that while there’s the complexity of the science, there’s also what we can do directly. And a whole foods diet, which again, food is medicine. I think is a really good message. One of the things is we talk about and think about carbohydrates. You you state in the book saturated fat is far less concerning than fast carbs. I would love to talk about fast carbs because you also write that ice cream is healthier than bread.
Speaker 1 42:30
I think the concept of fast carbs is is entering kind of the public’s consciousness, and people think about sugar and added sugar, but they generally don’t think about starch and refined grains. And one of the key messages that I try to explain to people is that white bread or white rice or crack or crackers or really any other refined starch, the molecular formula of that is glucose, right? It’s chains of glucose, and so actually the glycemic index test, which you know you’re familiar with and many of your listeners may be familiar with, the standard that you that you use, the highest glycemic index is either 100 grams of pure glucose or white bread. They have the equivalent glycemic index, and white bread, in fact, has a higher glycemic index than sugar. Sugar has a lower glycemic index because it’s glucose and fructose together, not not just glucose. Starch or sugar are in a natural intact food, so if you eat, you know, an apple, or if you have steel cut oats, or if you have a bean, or if you have a vegetable with some starch in it, in its natural intact structure, the enzymes in your mouth and in your stomach and in your small intestine have struggle to access and get at that starch, and so it’s digested very slowly. It has a slow glycemic index. Some of the calories actually aren’t digested by us at all. They get to the large gut, and our our bacteria digest them. That’s why they’re there. So they actually digest some of the calories, which means if you have 200 calories and they’re minimally processed, your bacteria might be digesting 20% of those. In contrast, if you have a ultra processed fast carb, it’s going to be digested very very quickly in the in the mouth and the stomach and the small intestine. You’re going to get a burst of of glucose into your bloodstream. You’re going to starve your gut microbiome, you know, which which has all kinds of negative consequences for gut health and chronic inflammation. And so this is really one of the big issues of our day. And and the challenge is of course if you know a lot you can understand that you know steel cut oats is different than instant oats is different than a processed whole oat cereal there’s a gradient there but what if you’re just trying to look at packages and make decisions about an energy bar or a cereal bar these other things and so I use two rules of thumb to try to kind of understand carbs and understand carb quality if it’s not a whole food, if it’s a packaged food, here’s to kind of two rules of thumb. The first is is the the carb to fiber ratio. People are looking at sugar, but again, worry about sugar because you could have a product with no sugar and it’s all starch, and that’s actually just as bad. And so instead of looking at just sugar, make sure that any food you eat. Has a reasonable amount of fiber to carbohydrate, and so let me operationalize that. If a product has 10 grams of carbohydrate, it should have at least one gram of fiber, 10 to one ratio. If it has 40 grams of carbohydrate, it should have at least four grams of fiber. So that 10 to one ratio, at least one gram of fiber for every 10 grams of carb, is a useful rule of thumb, because it roughly encapsulates the total carbohydrate quality of the product. What are its relative amounts of refined grains and starches and sugars versus whole grains and fiber and bran? And the lower the ratio, the better. So a ratio of five to one. Let’s say you have you know 40 grams of of carbohydrate and eight grams of fiber. That’s five to one. That’s even better. So that’s one rule of thumb, and and you know I recommend people use it. They look at their products in the grocery store or in their pantries, and make sure you have everything having a 10 to one ratio or better. And then the second rule of thumb, because that doesn’t get at food structure, right?
Speaker 1 45:54
The the Cheerios and steel cut oats have the same ratio because they’re both whole grains, whole oats in that case, so so that doesn’t get its structure and and kind of what you talked about about the intact food matrix. So my other general rule of thumb is the water test, and you could do this in real life, or you could just just you know visualize it. Take any carb-rich product and picture putting it in water, and come back two or three hours later. Right? What is it going to look like? If it’s going to be mush, then you know that’s what’s going to happen in your digestive system pretty quickly. If it’s going to be fairly intact, you know that it’s going to be digested more slowly as a general rule of thumb. And so again, the the Cheerio versus the steel cut oat, they’re nutritionally identical, but the Cheerio is more processed, and so it’s not a terrible cereal. I’m not saying Cheerios is terrible, but it’s not as good as steel cut oats. So I think it’s it’s those are just kind of two rules of thumb to navigate the the aisle because we can’t eliminate for most Americans processed and packaged foods. It
Speaker 2 46:46
would be nearly impossible.
Speaker 1 46:48
So we have to understand how to navigate the the grocery aisle.
Speaker 2 46:50
What about the ultra processed food defined by the Nova classification system? Do you think that that is important? I know that this is you know central to this organizing concept of of modern nutrition.
Speaker 1 47:02
Yeah, so ultra processed foods is a very new concept, and it was created by Dr. Carlos Montero, a friend of mine in Brazil. And the classification system is called Nova. And people say, “Well, what does Nova stand for? And I explain that. Well, writing his first paper in Portuguese, he wrote, “I propose a Nova classification system in Portuguese, which means new. So the word just means new. He was proposing a new classification system. So that’s all nova means is new. His fundamental concept, which I think was very important, was that beyond nutrients, there’s something about modern food that’s making us sick. And so ultra processing is not about salt or sugar or other common nutrients. It’s about the processing. That was his insight. And so today, there’s been at least 100 studies from around the world showing that people who have more ultra-processed foods have more disease, diabetes, cancer, obesity, mental health, many other conditions. And there have been three randomized trials, short-term, all short-term trials, but all showing that people who eat more ultra-processed foods overeat and gain weight, even when they’re matched on salt and sugar and and and fiber and other things. So I think that that concept, that Nova classification of ultra processed foods, is very important. And what we need today is a clear national definition. 15 states have now passed various laws to address ultra processed foods, and they’re all a little bit different. And so it’s driving industry crazy, which maybe isn’t a bad thing to try to understand how every state’s going to define ultra processed foods a little bit different. Which
Speaker 2 48:27
also makes no sense, right? Shouldn’t we have a unified definition?
Speaker 1 48:32
A research definition is one thing. Nova definition works great for research, but for policy, you have to be really, really explicit, right? What defines an ultra processed food? And so the simplest definition, which people members of the public can can use, is that if it has an ingredient in there that’s not used in a home kitchen, it’s ultra processed. And so, you know, a potato chip that’s just potatoes, oil, and salt is not ultra processed, but a potato chip that’s potatoes, oil, and salt, and flavorings and colorings and you know other preservatives is going to be ultra processed, and that’s also true for cereals and breads and and other things. It’s not the only metric, so we can’t say every food that’s ultra processed is bad for you. That’s not true, and we can’t say every food that’s not ultra processed is good for you. That’s not true. It’s one additional dimension that I think is important to add. And so, on average, ultra processed foods are bad for us, and on average, foods that are not are good for us, with again some variation. And and so what I’m excited about is, from what I’ve heard, there is going to be a definition of ultra processed foods released by the administration this this year, and maybe it’ll be out by the time this plays. Yeah, that would
Speaker 2 49:35
be very exciting. Yeah, because you know one of the the challenges I think in science is that we have to have a common language, otherwise my definition of ultra-processed food, for example, a whey protein shake would be considered a processed food, but would it be considered ultra-processed? I suppose if it had within that criteria that you’re talking about, but is that super convenient? Does it? What if it had alpha-lactal? Human in it, and and some of these other components.
Speaker 1 50:02
I think that’s really important. Processing by itself is not bad, right? We need to process food, and so in the Nova classification system, there is a classification of just processed, and so foods that have are processed, like again the potato chip that’s clean, or an artisanal bread, or canned tuna fish, or jarred vegetables, are processed, but they’re not ultra processed, and so adding vitamins, adding nutrients, adding whey protein-that’s not ultra processing, right? Ultra processing is about functional additives that change sweetness, change preservation, change other functional characteristics of the food. It’s not that all of those additives are harmful. Some of them may be okay. Some of them are are definitely harmful, but it’s that that combination of factors just identifies this this class of foods. And I think what’s really interesting is if we took a lot of those additives out, even if they weren’t harmful, people couldn’t eat the food anymore, right? Because it just wouldn’t taste good. I mean, in a way, you can think about this as all of these things are added because the quality of the ingredients is so poor that they just wouldn’t be edible without all all of these admins.
Speaker 2 51:03
Sounds like my cooking.
Speaker 1 51:04
Yeah, something. No, no,
Speaker 2 51:06
it’s terrible. We try to eat whole foods whenever we can. It’s very important to us. But I know that there are people that are really busy and on the run. The thing about my husband, my husband who was so proud, he ran to work this morning in the in the Texas heat with 30 pounds on his his pack, and and he brings a little you know tart cherry shot with with him. In his mind, he is eating healthy, and I’m I’m not picking on you, Shane, but there might be additives like carrageen, which you mentioned might have positive benefits, and that’s an additive. But for a person who is looking at this and listening to this and reading your book, obviously they’re going to have the answers. But when the rubber meets the road, is there one heuristic guide point for them?
Speaker 1 51:56
Yeah. Well, two things. I mean, first, there is a guide, and then second, we have to have policies to make the foods that are good for us, you know, really, really the simple and easy choice. The way I think about foods, Gabrielle, is three categories, right? There’s foods that are protective that we should be embracing and eating more of, not counting calories, not watching portion sizes. Everyone be angry with you about this. Eating more of these, right? There’s foods kind of in the middle that are those are the foods to eat in moderation, and there’s foods kind of at the bottom that are really unhealthy and we should avoid or minimize. Maybe maybe not never, but but minimize. And so those are kind of the three groups. At the top you have mostly minimally processed plant foods, but not only so fruits and vegetables and nuts and seeds and beans and true minimally processed whole grains, not necessarily commercial, commercially processed whole grains.
Speaker 2 52:46
Meaning something like a steel cut oat,
Speaker 1 52:48
right? Like a steel cut oat or wheat berries or amaranth, right? A true structurally intact or stone ground. A stone ground bread is the stone grinding means it’s structurally intact, and then also fish and yogurt, you know, belong in that category. Yogurt with its with its probiotics and fermentation, and fish with its omega threes, and so those are the foods we should just be embracing. And and plant oils, all kinds of plant oils, should be in that category too. You think that yeah,
Speaker 2 53:12
you mean added plant oil or just in general polyunsaturated oils?
Speaker 1 53:17
Yeah, any any any any plant oil really is is is good for us. From nuts or seeds or fruits are all delicious and healthy. And then in the middle, the food seed in moderation are mostly minimally other minimally processed animal foods, and so butter, chicken, eggs, milk and cheese, and and unprocessed red meat all kind of go in the middle. And in that list, I would put cheese a little bit higher as as a fermented food. We’ve talked about you know cheese and its potential benefits, and I’d put red meat a little bit lower on the list.
Speaker 2 53:44
This is the one thing, friends, we disagree on. I’d
Speaker 1 53:46
put red meat a little lower on the list of foods to eat in moderation because it it generates compounds in in the gut that can increase risk of cancer and and are pro-inflammatory and it can increase risk of diabetes.
Speaker 2 53:57
Are you talking about TMAO?
Speaker 1 53:58
TMAO is one compound. There’s sulfur-containing compounds that are carcinogenic. There’s pro-inflammatory compounds like iron. Iron is quite pro-inflammatory, actually. And so, a serving or two a week of unprocessed red meat is fine. But I think
Speaker 2 54:11
I disagree.
Speaker 1 54:12
But but I think for most people, I think more than that is is problematic. At the bottom, and I think this is where we do agree, is all the ultra-processed foods that are particularly high in starch and sugar and salt, and not fat, sugar and salt. That’s a combo of words that’s thrown around. It’s starch, sugar, and salt. And so, if you think of these these three kind of categories, this explains actually even maybe some of where we don’t actually disagree. If people are eating an average American diet with like cotton candy and refined breakfast cereals and white bread and just all the junk that that people eat, if they move up the up the categories and they’re eating red meat all the time, it’s healthier for sure. They’re going to be better off to be eating steak every day than to be eating white bread every day. But they should even better than the steak or the cheese or the or the milk would be to have nuts and seeds and yogurt. And of course, they can have a mix. They can have a mix of those foods. And so that’s kind of the hierarchy of foods is those three categories. And as you’ve noted, there are also interactions and depends on your own your own personal health issues and and potentially microbiome. I’m not saying eat a plant based diet, right? Plants are at the top, some of the healthiest foods, and plants are at the bottom, right? Fries and a coat is an 8%
Speaker 2 55:19
of our plant based proteins coming from wheat.
Speaker 1 55:22
I mean, most of the worst things in diet are plant-based, right? So it’s all the refined starch and sugar and ultra-processed foods. So, so plant-based doesn’t doesn’t work. If you said minimally processed whole food, plant-based, that’s better. But why not have cheese and and and yogurt and and other and fish and other foods as well? And it’s not everything in moderation, right? I like
Speaker 2 55:40
that. What do you mean? It’s not everything in moderation. Well,
Speaker 1 55:42
you want to eat the good stuff as much as possible, and you want to eat the bad stuff as little as possible. That’s the opposite of everything in moderation. Someone told me, and I have to confirm this, that everything in moderation-that the phrase was actually created by Coca-Cola in its marketing, even if they didn’t create it, even if that’s not true. Have the
Speaker 2 55:57
team look that up? Yeah,
Speaker 1 55:59
it’s definitely an industry message, right? Everything in moderation means everything to anyone.
Speaker 2 56:04
I I couldn’t agree with you more.
Speaker 1 56:06
So I think a lot of the things that people think of as simple rules doesn’t mean organic because I’d rather have you have an inorganic peach than an organic white bread, right? So simple rules don’t work. You really have to think about food quality.
Speaker 2 56:18
I have a few questions as we think about nuts, seeds, fruits, and vegetables. With the decreasing quality of our soil, do we have to consume more? So the pint of blueberries that we used to have 100 years ago, compared to the pint of blueberries that we need now for optimal health, do you think that we can reconcile the two?
Speaker 1 56:39
There have been surprisingly few studies actually looking at this question, as important as it is. But the studies that have looked, handful of studies, have definitely found that crops from 30 or 40 years ago, or crops grown in very traditional ways today, have considerably more nutrients than than kind of conventionally grown, industrially grown crops, and also fewer contaminants, contaminants from pesticides and contaminants from other things in depleted soil and and in water that’s been contaminated. It’s a double hit, right? We’re both lowering the nutrients and increasing the contaminants. And some of those differences are are pretty extreme. If you look at even rice or wheat or other foods, fewer studies have looked at fruit or other other things because it’s hard to compare, right?
Speaker 3 57:18
Yeah.
Speaker 1 57:18
But the studies that have looked at regeneratively grown fruit or regeneratively grown livestock also tend to show more positive nutrients, and interestingly, for livestock, less pro-inflammatory compounds. And so, I do wonder if we grew all our beef through regenerative methods, if they would have less pro-inflammatory effects and not be as much of a concern for diabetes or cancer. But as I mentioned, it’s just shocking we don’t know the answer to your question that well, but all the directional science we have, you know, is is in agreement with what what you said. Basically, from as I mentioned, from Norman Borlaug and the Green Revolution from the 1950s to the 1970s, he worked to develop modern agriculture because the population went from one and a half billion in 1900 to 6 billion in 2000. In those 100 years, more humans were born than in all of prior human history combined. And so demographers looked at that in the 1950s and said, “There’s we don’t we don’t have enough food. If you just look at our land and look at the the acreage and look at the yield, we’re going to starve. And so his methods increased the yield per acre for wheat or corn, eventually rice by over 10 or 20 fold, 1,000% or 2,000% higher yield. And so, with Norman Borlaug’s innovations, Mexico and India and Pakistan within five years went from being on the brink of famine to being food exporting nations. So we have to first again give credit for modern agriculture to to do that. But what that did is it set up a system where all we’ve cared about is production, production, production, quantity, quantity, quantity, cost, cost, cost, and so everything, all of our all of our science around agriculture, has been just focused on quantity. And I think what’s been lost is not only nutrients, but taste and flavor. Go to most grocery stores today and get a tomato, or get a peach, or even a banana, even corn, and it doesn’t taste that good, right? But go to Italy in the summer from a local farm and get a peach, or get a nectarine, or in the United States from some somewhere, and the flavor is incredible, right? So generations of Americans are growing up not realizing what real food tastes like.
Speaker 2 59:22
My concern is that six out of 10 Americans have some form of chronic disease. The majority of kids growing up now have a very high risk of becoming obese. We’re overfed, but we’re undernourished, and I don’t see in a world where we’re going to be able to get the amount of polyphenols that we need again. I don’t know if supplementation is the answer. Have you thought about that?
Speaker 1 59:45
Well, fortunately, the science we have for the benefits of these foods is based on the current modern foods, and so even as depleted as they are, they’re still linked in observational studies to all these health benefits. And in the trials that we’ve done, it’s pretty much the traditional foods that add. We’ve eaten. So the good news is, even a depleted fruit or nut or seed is still pretty good for us. You’re right, though. We could supercharge that, right? And maybe not need to eat as much if we could actually return to to a better time. Yeah.
Speaker 2 1:00:13
And I really appreciate that you’re giving me some hope. Can we talk a little bit about the dietary guideline recommendations, higher protein. You and I, we at least last time I checked, we really like each other. I think you’re amazing, but there is in that protein component. I think that we just don’t see eye to eye. And in order to just have transparent conversation, for example, if we worry about TMAO, fish is the is a higher producer of TMAO, and so can you give me your perspective on the dietary guideline recommendations for higher protein?
Speaker 1 1:00:48
Well, one of the things that struck me about the dietary guidelines first is that the media stories and even some of my peers really had a kind of a biased summary of what they say. So people have called them sort of the red meat and butter guidelines. I actually just read an editorial yesterday about them that said you know the guidelines recommend more red meat. There’s nothing in the guidelines anywhere, anywhere that says that people should eat more red meat. Just doesn’t say that actually. So the first thing is to read read the guidelines. Now, in defense of the media and those people, there have been administration officials who have done tweets or done videos where like a huge steak or butter is back, so the messaging has been a little bit kind of pro red meat or pro butter, but the actual guidelines are fairly balanced, and so I think the guidelines are pretty good. So first, when it comes to protein sources, all the guidelines say is to have your protein from real food, which is the first time it’s ever said that, not from supplements and shakes and powders and processed foods and protein bars and protein drinks, but to have it from real food, and then second to have it from a range of foods, and so it says to have it from meat, poultry, chicken, eggs, lentils, soy, nuts, seeds, all the sources, and every dietary guidelines has said that actually for for 100 years to have your protein from a range of sources. So so I just think it’s really important that the guidelines don’t say to eat more red meat. They just say to have your protein from real food from a range of sources, which I agree with. I think the only thing that I that I would have changed a little bit, and I think the only place we disagree a little bit, is they increased the protein target to about 1.2 to 1.6 grams of protein per per kilogram of ideal body weight per day, I think that’s a very appropriate target for somebody that’s strength training, and you strength train, and your husband strength train. You showed me your beautiful gym here outside the studio. Whoever
Speaker 2 1:02:30
worked out of Dan is
Speaker 1 1:02:31
left. Well, you strength train. I try to when I can, and so for people who are strength training, which should be everybody, the protein guidelines are perfectly fine. What I worry about is most Americans aren’t strength training, and if you’re not strength training, the old original targets were just fine. And so, what I really worry about is not so much the recommendation, because again, if you have a little more, a little less protein from real food, it’s not going to be bad for your health. What I really worry about is industry manipulating those guidelines to create more processed products that are high in protein, and in fact, we’ve we’ve seen it happen in the last month. So we have high protein pop tarts with high protein Cheetos. We have my wife went to Costco the day after the guidelines, and they had replaced not the end caps, but like behind where where all the checkouts are. There’s all these. I don’t know if you’ve been to Costco. They had replaced everything there with protein bars and protein shakes. So what I really worry about is is not explaining to people that higher protein is needed if you’re strength training, and if you’re not strength training, every American is already getting enough protein. There’s no protein deficiency in the United States if you’re not strength training.
Speaker 2 1:03:33
Strength training helps sensitize the body, right? So it stimulates muscle protein synthesis. It increases efficiency. If someone is sedentary, the way to stimulate their muscle is either going to be dietary protein or resistance training. So I guess my question is, how do you think about supporting the aging muscle?
Speaker 1 1:03:56
You know, you’re probably more of an expert at this than I am, having worked worked your own work and Don Layman, but from all my reading of the literature and the review I did for the book, studies in older people who are you know at risk for sarcopenia or aging have all shown that if you do strength training and protein, that that helps hold muscle. But just dietary protein alone does not help maintain muscle. You need to do the strength training. The
Speaker 2 1:04:18
strength training and protein, that synergistic effect, is so you know as a geriatrician that’s so helpful for aging. Yeah. The other thing is I think beyond muscle, with the decrease in protein turnover, if we’re replacing 300 grams of protein a day in our body, which we do, we’re always going through protein turnover. We become less efficient, and I just get concerned if people are inactive, under-consuming protein, because the RDS is set at the minimum, I just, I really worry about beyond muscle. You know, glutathione production, mucin production, just all of those things.
Speaker 1 1:04:53
Well, the average protein intake in the United States right now is about 16 or 17% of calories.
Speaker 2 1:04:58
1.1 gram.
Speaker 1 1:05:00
And so it’s about 1.1. So it’s already above that minimum of 0.8. Only about 10% of Americans are around that 0.8 or lower, and it tends to be older older women in particular. So you’re right. If you’re you know over 65 and you’re a woman and you’re not eating a lot of animal products, you may be in that in in that group. But for 90% of Americans, they’re already above that 0.8, and so I’m less worried about
Speaker 2 1:05:23
it. If someone is sitting here thinking about how they design a diet, you talk about the fiber ratio, which is really important. Do you have any concerns about the amount of carbs at any one given meal?
Speaker 1 1:05:33
You know, ultimately, the quality of the diet matters more than the amount of carb or protein or fat in a meal on average. But I generally tend to tell people to try to to you know have at least 50% of their calories from fat as a general rule, and
Speaker 2 1:05:48
then and
Speaker 1 1:05:49
then if you have 15 or 20% as protein, then your carb is only you know about about 35% of calories or 30% of calories, and so I think that’s probably the healthiest diet in the American food system is to be relatively modestly low carb. Of course, you could have a higher carb diet if you’re really careful and are really careful about the carbs you eat. But again, I think that’s the general rule. And and all the studies that have been done show that higher fat diets, especially diets that are higher in plant fats and seafood fats, are unbelievably healthy.
Speaker 2 1:06:19
So it seems as if things are really targeted towards kids, the the packaged products, and there’s also the SNAP program. Do you think that we’re going to see changes in that?
Speaker 1 1:06:31
Well, here’s where we get into policy, and I think it’s really important. For too long, especially in the United States, we have this image of like the cowboy, you know, the individual rugged. We
Speaker 2 1:06:39
are in Texas.
Speaker 1 1:06:41
Individual American, you know, out on everything on their own back, and when you have, you know, one in three kids, one in three teens has pre-diabetes in this country, and that’s
Speaker 2 1:06:51
that’s it’s up it’s so upsetting. One in three teens, right, has pre-diabetes. I mean, one in three. One in three. That is, it’s
Speaker 1 1:06:58
outrageous, right? It’s also our
Speaker 2 1:06:59
responsibility.
Speaker 1 1:07:00
And you have three and four adults have overweight or obesity, and you have half of adults have diabetes or pre-diabetes. The system is broken, right? So I think that’s really important that we can’t blame the individual and say it’s just on you to go make good choices. There’s a few categories of things we have to fix, and my rule is the Willie Sutton rule. And so Willie Sutton was a bank robber in the 1920s who was arrested. Look at my
Speaker 2 1:07:24
notes. I’m like, where’s the Willie Sutton rule? He
Speaker 1 1:07:27
robbed a bunch of banks. He was arrested. He escaped from jail. He robbed banks again. He was arrested, and he kind of became a folk hero. Actually, it was kind of people were kind of excited about Willie Sutton, and when they asked him like, why you why why do you keep robbing banks? Willie said, because that’s where the money is. So my policy rule is you you go where the money is, right? And so the biggest pot of money by far in our in our economy is healthcare. Right, healthcare is $5.5 trillion, trillion. Again, we it’s hard to put and wrap our minds around numbers, but another way to think about is the average family of four. It’s $50,000 per year suspension healthcare. So think of what the average family of four spends on housing and food and transportation vacations. It’s not $50,000, right? So we’re spending more on healthcare than than almost anything else for the average family. That’s where food is medicine comes in. And then I think the next biggest bucket of money is our federal nutrition programs, and that includes SNAP, which used to be called food stamps, and school meals and WIC are the three biggest ones. WIC is the one for for women. And what’s the difference
Speaker 2 1:08:24
between the SNAP and the WIC? Yeah, so SNAP
Speaker 1 1:08:27
is the biggest one. It’s 100 billion, so it’s $100 billion. It’s by far the biggest one. And then school meals. I might get the numbers wrong, but I think it’s roughly 15 15 billion or 20 billion. And then WIC is just for women who are pregnant, nursing, and kids under five.
Speaker 2 1:08:40
I see kids under five. Yeah, and so it’s really
Speaker 1 1:08:42
for families, and it has it has more generous eligibility criteria than SNAP. And so many women who are not eligible for SNAP are still eligible for for WIC. That’s $140 billion, and I think that’s really important to shift that that spending. And then the next bucket is the NIH, which we talked about, the National Institutes of Health. That’s $50 billion, and then probably the next you know bigger bucket is institutional procurement: what hospitals buy, what employers buy, what what what we buy in our community for events. You know, kind of the dollars we spend. So we can kind of go down the list, and and there’s and there’s other items. But my key point is we’re already spending the money. What’s really exciting about fixing food, and what makes it I think nonpartisan and not controversial is I’m not asking for more money. We’re not asking anybody to spend more money. We’re actually asking to shift our dollars that we’re already spending towards healthy food, and in doing so, we’ll actually save money because people will be less sick, and we won’t spend as much on healthcare. We won’t have lost human productivity. We won’t have families going bankrupt. The number one cause of individual bankruptcy is is medical bills, and we know, of course, the number one cause of medical bills is diet related disease. So
Speaker 2 1:09:46
diet related disease does not blow your mind. It’s
Speaker 1 1:09:49
incredible. Yeah, estimated about 1.5 trillion a year is is due to directly due to poor nutrition. If we kind of go go down that list, all of those things are important. And what’s really interesting is school. Meals and WIC have very clear nutrition standards. WIC is pretty much a minimally processed basket. It’s like
Speaker 2 1:10:07
has it always been that, or WIC was
Speaker 1 1:10:08
always that way. And WIC was created out of this conference that Jean Mayer and Nixon did. It was intended to give pregnant women and nursing women and young children healthy food, and so it’s basically a package of fruits and vegetables and whole grains and nuts and seeds and dairy and chicken and eggs and just basically a package of healthy food, minimally processed food. School meals has had its fits and starts, but after 2010, when the Healthy Hunger Free Kids Act passed Congress, school meals has actually improved quite a bit. It may not taste very good, but from or look or look very good. But amazingly, what’s really shocking and sad is, from a pure nutritional perspective, we showed this. It’s healthier than the average food they eat from grocery stores or restaurants. And so, as bad as it is, school meals are actually okay. Like
Speaker 2 1:10:51
how positive you are.
Speaker 1 1:10:52
And SNAP, interestingly, is is is the biggest program. Doesn’t have any nutrition standards.
Speaker 2 1:10:56
People don’t realize that.
Speaker 1 1:10:57
Yes. So that’s what really sets it apart from school meals in WIC, which were fundamentally created as nutrition programs, SNAP was created in the Great Depression to solve two problems at the same time. You had families that were poor and couldn’t put food on the table, and you had farmers that had that had crops and couldn’t sell them. So SNAP was literally created by law to both help American food industry and help poor American families, and so that kind of dual goal, which today is actually kind of a a competing goal, right? We want to support American food industry with with dollars, and we want to support families with dollars. That’s why there’s nutrition standards,
Speaker 2 1:11:36
you know. And as we kind of just think about how this all fits together, is that SNAP and WIC-they are informed. Are they informed by the dietary guidelines?
Speaker 1 1:11:45
So WIC is, and school meals is, but not SNAP. Is
Speaker 2 1:11:48
there a place where it will be?
Speaker 1 1:11:50
So SNAP is is paid for by the federal government, but it’s administered by the states. Right. And like most programs that are administered by the states, the states have the opportunity to experiment and try new things and apply for what’s called a waiver to USDA to say I want to try something new and and report how it works, and so multiple states, mostly Democratic states, over the years have tried to, for example, restrict sugar sweetened beverages and SNAP. So Minnesota, Maine, New York, in previous years, all asked USDA, can we try restricting sugar sweetened beverages or soda? And interestingly, both Republican and Democratic administrations always said no, and they always had an excuse. They said no because of this or that, or your program’s too big, or kind of vague reasons. And I’ve looked at looked at all those all of those those reasoning. This administration said yes, we’re we’re willing to try these new experiments. And so today, 23 states, 23 states have now said for the next two or three years, we’re going to try taking out soda and/or candy and junk food from SNAP, and we’re going to evaluate it. We’re going to see what happens. What happens to people’s purchasing? Do they just replace the SNAP dollars with their own money and not improve their health at all? Do they improve their health? Does it cause more stigma? Does it cause confusion? Is it a problem? Is it positive? Is it negative? I don’t know what the answer to that will be, but I think it’s important that that states are being given the the option to try this and and to evaluate it.
Speaker 2 1:13:08
Do you think that there is a place where food industry really gets pressure?
Speaker 1 1:13:12
Well, this is massive pressure for food industry, right? People talk about the farm subsidies, right? That’s about 30 billion a year. This is 100 billion. So the biggest government handout to the industry directly to food manufacturers essentially is SNAP, and so they are absolutely terrified of changes to SNAP and fight it tooth and nail. There are people who fight it for moral or ethical reasons. They say, “Well, why should we be telling you know low income Americans what to buy or what not to buy? They have their you know own personal beliefs around that, but I think food industry is fighting it because it affects their bottom line. And so, even when SNAP benefits changed after COVID, Kraft said our mac and cheese sales plummeted. You know, when when SNAP benefits were reduced after COVID, so this directly affects the bottom line of food manufacturers. It’s a bit it’s a big deal politically.
Speaker 2 1:13:57
And if you say we should follow the money, which I agree, whereas the money now we have increased use of GLP ones, which obviously we’re still really struggling with obesity. Do you think that that is going to affect overall consumption in general?
Speaker 1 1:14:13
Well, so GLP ones, which are last year 140 billion were spent on GLP ones, and to put that in perspective, a couple years before the total pharmacy spend in this country on all drugs was 600 billion, right? So already 25% above what the the spend was just on GLP ones alone. And the other point I want to make about GLP ones is they can be an effective treatment. I’m not against the drug, but they’re so expensive that even with the health benefits and the obesity reductions-they’re not cost savings, right? We’re still spending money to to buy health, and we’re spending a lot of money to buy health. So, so they’re just too expensive to to be cost saving. So, we’re not going to see see an ROI other than, of course, health gains. We’re not going to see $1 ROI. I think there’s many fascinating things about GLP ones. I think I think first some. Some people who aren’t really experts in nutrition think that this is going to do away with the need for nutrition, right? That why do we even care anymore? And I’ve actually heard obesity experts sort of say that, like, why do we even care about? That’s
Speaker 2 1:15:09
kind of sad.
Speaker 1 1:15:10
It’s shocking. Like very smart people say, why do we care about prevention? Why do we care about nutrition? We have the GLP on drugs now. I think actually the opposite is happening now that that payers who pay for these drugs are seeing that people go on them, go off them, regain the weight. That these are not a silver bullet. These are not a magic bullet by themselves. And we have to prescribe them with wraparound lifestyle, including nutrition. So I actually think they’re tailwinds to food as medicine and nutrition, because by FDA regulation, GLP ones were approved as an obesity treatment as an adjunct to nutrition and lifestyle, not the other way around. I see patients in Chinatown in in downtown Boston, and I saw a patient earlier this year who came to the clinic, had you know severe obesity, diabetes, many other conditions, in his mid 40s, right, very very sick, and he had just been started on a GLP-1 drug by his primary care doctor, which was appropriate for all of his conditions. And he was seeing me for the first time for chest pain. You know, he likely had developed heart disease in his 40s. And I asked him, I said, you know, did your doctor tell you anything about nutrition? And he said, no, he didn’t really mention anything. And I said, well, what’s your diet like? And he said, “I have a pretty good diet. And usually in the clinic, I say, “What do you have for breakfast? What do you have for lunch? What do you have for dinner? What are your snacks? And you can get a pretty good sense of it. But before I could say that, he said, “I have a pretty good diet. His his wife was on a speakerphone, and she said, “Tell him about the Coca Cola. I can’t do a good Boston accent. She’s like, “Tell him about the good. Yeah, I was close. No, not even close. He says, “Oh yeah, I drink Coke How much do you drink? He said. He said 10 cans a day. And I paused and I said, Did your doctor tell you maybe you shouldn’t drink the Coca Cola now that you’re on the GPU? And he said he never mentioned it. You know, to me, like using these drugs on top of all the other drugs and and devices and things we do in healthcare without fundamentally addressing nutrition, I think is is a massive economic mistake. To get to your question of of what is it going to do to taste? To me, that’s one of the most interesting things about the GLP ones, Gabrielle, is that some people, not all, their tastes actually change. And there was a great New York Magazine article about this that I talk about in the book, where people who craved ho hos and Doritos and Twinkies and candy can not only not only don’t crave it, but went back and tried it, and it felt they felt sick.
Speaker 2 1:17:24
And we hear that in clinic. I don’t know if you are hearing that in your clinic. I’ve
Speaker 1 1:17:28
seen some patients that happen. Yeah, and and and they actually crave cherries and lettuce and fish and yogurt and healthy foods. That’s
Speaker 2 1:17:35
never happened in our clinic. But no, no,
Speaker 1 1:17:37
they they I’ve I’ve seen it, and this article talks about it. They crave healthy foods. They can’t eat unhealthy foods, and so to me, that’s how I feel all the time. Like I genuinely, people ask me, “Well, you know, unhealthy food tastes good. I said, “Unhealthy food tastes terrible. It tastes awful. Like healthy food is really what’s delicious. And so I’ve always, I think I’ve just been lucky. I’ve had normal GLP-1 signaling, whether it’s through epigenetics and in utero influences, or just my mother’s home Persian cooking, or a good microbiome, or whatever good fortune I’ve had, I have normal GLP-1 signaling. And so, what’s interesting is, for some people at least, I think what GLP-1s show us is that the human brain and body is not hardwired to like ultra-processed foods. I think that’s
Speaker 2 1:18:16
that’s a good a good point.
Speaker 1 1:18:18
We’re sick. I think if you crave ultra-processed foods, it’s because your GLP one isn’t probably working correctly, your microbiome isn’t producing the short chain fatty acids and other molecules that support GLP one signaling in the brain. And what’s exciting to me is for 30 years people have sold this sort of story that the food industry has hooked us on fat, sugar, and salt. That we’re hardwired biologically to eat this the thrifty gene hypothesis, and that’s such a dark and pessimistic outlook because it means the the food that’s worst for us is the food we crave. And I think what GLP ones are showing us is probably we have a national, you know, epidemic of GLP one insufficiency or GLP one resistance, just like diabetes is you know insulin resistance or deficiency, and GLP ones aren’t working properly in most people’s brains because of all these environmental influences, and so I think that’s what’s really exciting is if we can restore GLP one functioning through food and maybe through drugs, if we have to, we actually can show that people really do crave healthy food, and that creates the market incentive for companies to make healthy food.
Speaker 2 1:19:20
Heather Lydie was one of the pioneers in this area, where she would show in teens that if an individual had 30 grams of protein, that GLP one was released, CCK, all kinds of things. You know, it makes me think about the protein leverage hypothesis that as people are under eating protein in the group that is, because their food calories are so dilute that as they get towards 15 to 20% normal satiety mechanisms seem to turn on or become more regulated. I, I just think that there’s probably a role for correcting just our. Macronutrients in general.
Speaker 1 1:20:01
Almost all people eat protein somewhere between 15 and 20% of their calories, whatever however much they’re eating. And it’s hard to eat more, and it’s actually kind of hard to eat less. So unless again, people have challenges with with cooking or income or other things, but naturally, we sort of gravitate towards that that protein consumption. I think it’s quite interesting. And the other thing that’s interesting about GLP ones is they’re a hormone released by the by the intestines in response to food, and so many people don’t even know that, right? That that that’s a hormone that should be released in response to food, and many of the things that have been discovered that increase the the release of GLP ones are the same things we’ve talked about in the foods, not just protein. You’re right, but also also healthy fats, also polyphenols and other micronutrients that that release GLP one. But what’s really interesting to me is that the half life of GLP one in the bloodstream is just minutes, and yet when you eat a food and the GLP one goes up, the natural GLP one, the natural GLP one from our intestines, you feel full for hours, and so scientists are untangling why that is when the actual molecule is only there for minutes. But it really does appear that when you eat healthy food and GLP one goes up, your microbiome digests some of the the nutrients if you have a true healthy diet, and the metabolites go into the bloodstream and go to the brain and actually interact with those same GLP one receptors. And so probably most natural GLP-1 signaling isn’t from the GLP-1 molecule itself; it’s from microbiome metabolites that that interact with with GLP-1 pathways. And so again, it just highlights how quality of the diet is so important to be able to have kind of long-term normal GLP-1 function in the brain.
Speaker 2 1:21:37
You’ve mentioned that we’re at a tipping point. Five years from now, where do you think we’re going to be?
Speaker 1 1:21:41
I mean, I think the pessimist or the realist would say incremental progress, right? A little bit better on some of these things, a little bit more public awareness, lots more marketing and industry marketing, and confusing people that this is the next superfood for sleep and for energy, and you know, take take this drink and take that drink. That’s what you said. The next soil. That’s the pessimist. Okay, right? I want
Speaker 2 1:22:01
to hear the pessimists. The
Speaker 1 1:22:01
next soilent, the next you know this. Our soil is more depleted. Our water is is is is gone. More conflicts around the world because of of poor nutrition. Our economy is tanking. We’re taken over by many other nations in terms of our economy because we’re spending so much in healthcare.
Speaker 2 1:22:17
Don’t you think that was what we heard the last five years, and then the five years before that? It it
Speaker 1 1:22:20
it could it could all happen, right? This is the direction we’re going in. But the optimist in me sees that like five years ago, when I would go to Congress or I’d want to go to meetings and I talk about food as medicine, people saying, “What’s food is medicine, right? And then about three years ago, people would say, “Okay, I’ve heard of it, but why would we do it, right? What’s the evidence? And now, everywhere I go, people know what it is, have a sense of it, know why we should do it, and now the only question is how. The conversation has changed, and and I think to me the economic argument is the single biggest argument. If we use a health argument, or our children are suffering argument, or an environmental argument, most people unfortunately like perk up for a minute and then go back to their daily lives. But decision makers, if you talk about dollars, they pay attention. Again, we talked about the money. There’s at least a trillion dollars a year being left on the table for companies and governments to do the right thing. At least a trillion dollars. If we can recapture that trillion dollars, trillion. Imagine what we could do for education and defense and infrastructure and AI and all the things we’re trying to do in this country. So to me, I feel like we’re we’re at a tipping point. And so my hope is that five years from now, you can go to your doctor, and as part of standard of care, he can you know evaluate you for diet related disease, and if you meet the right criteria, he can prescribe the right healthy food as part of your treatment plan, just like prescribing a drug or a device or a surgery. I hope doctors will have a basic understanding of nutrition. They’re not going to be registered dietitians, but they know enough to be able to prescribe and understand and screen screen patients for nutrition. I hope that SNAP will have will have shifted and through whatever means works and works best without you know worsening stigma for participants or decreasing enrollment, SNAP will have shifted towards healthy food. I hope that school meals, the reimbursement is more than $4.60 per meal, and can actually pay for minimally processed, locally sourced food. I hope that we have a definition of ultra processed food, and we have procurement regulations. So, hospitals, major institutions, companies, employers say, “I’m not going to buy any more than 50 percent or no more than 25 percent of products for my cafeterias as ultra-processed foods. Right? I’m going to make sure we have we have whole foods. I hope that we have labeling and on the front to pack. You know, people can see is this food healthy, maybe with an overall score with just the FDA healthy icon, and is this food ultra processed? Very simple, right? Not numbers and nutrients. I I think it’s coming. I think this FDA is going to do that. And then I hope all of these different programs and platforms and dollars, including a major new program at the NIH in research, I hope all of them will actually focus on as much as they can buying the food. From local farms, from American farms, from regenerative farms, so that not only we’re making ourselves healthier, but we’re making our soil healthier. We’re increasing the economic resilience of our rural communities and our farmers who are really struggling today. And so, instead of an extractive food system, right? We we have an extractive food system today that that is extracting from our health, from our economy, from the earth. We have a restorative food system that’s nourishing our health, nourishing our economy, and nourishing our our soil and resources.
Speaker 2 1:25:27
I hope all those things come true. I I really do.
Speaker 1 1:25:30
I know you’ve been talking about it and and fighting for it yourself. You know, and and so many things you’ve been doing. Yeah,
Speaker 2 1:25:34
for years.
Speaker 1 1:25:35
Yeah,
Speaker 2 1:25:36
and the the question becomes who is responsible, and we can say everybody is responsible, but the policy and the big food companies-they have to make a change, right? If we’re in the checkout line and there’s a banana, because at you know the grocery store they do they have bananas and apples that the the kids get to pick, or there’s you know chips or puffs. I mean, it’s true. My kid is not like, oh, I can’t wait to eat the the banana. It would be difficult for her to have responsibility. But if this stuff wasn’t available and so easy to get, she would have a better chance.
Speaker 1 1:26:12
Well, this is where government has an essential role, right? I don’t think we need a nanny state telling us what to do. Government can’t fix all our problems, but but government, what it does well is it identifies an area of national interest, and it creates incentives and disincentives and carrots and sticks and and rules and regulations to level the playing field and to promote you know an outcome in the interest of the nation. And so you can look at what the country did with railroads when it wanted to build railroads across the country, or what it did with the auto industry when that was a national priority, and yet food, which arguably is a bigger issue and more important than any of those those things, because it’s foundational to to how our our lives, has mostly been ignored recently. And again, we have to kind of understand how we get here. If if you just go back to the 50s and 60s, the green revolution and the conquering of vitamin deficiency diseases wouldn’t have happened without government intervention, and so the recipe is pretty simple. It’s it’s we have the good science, we have government intervention to sort of create catalyze the movement, and then you have private sector innovation. That’s the catalyst. The public is responsible, of course, because they they drive the system with their dollars, but they also drive culture change. And so I think I think the public is really responsible for the culture change. They’re kind of the heat under the crucible, and then you know in the crucible you mix the science and the government and and and business innovation, and we could rapidly rapidly you know solve these problems.
Speaker 2 1:27:36
Food is medicine. It is out October 20. We’re gonna link everything here in just one word. What do you What do you hope for the people listening to this?
Speaker 1 1:27:46
One word, a one sentence, two
Speaker 2 1:27:48
sentences. Yes,
Speaker 1 1:27:48
I hope that people realize that what they eat is among the most important daily decisions and daily influences for not only for their own bodies, but for their families and for the earth and for the economy, and and that it’s not that complicated, but it does take some effort. And and that if we actually focus on food, we can improve our own health, we can improve our family’s health, our community, our nation, and ultimately, you know, kind of fix fix a failing planet.
Speaker 2 1:28:13
If someone has not thanked you, you’ve been investing tirelessly in just making a better world. So thank you.
Speaker 1 1:28:22
Well, thank you. I still feel like the young upstart, like out there to kind of shake things up. Probably will always be that way. But I’ve been doing doing it for a long time, and I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you to you as well.
Speaker 2 1:28:32
Thank you.














