now playing
Do You Need More Essential Amino Acids Than The Official Figures Say? | Dr. David Church
Episode 228, duration 58 mins
Episode 228
Do You Need More Essential Amino Acids Than The Official Figures Say? | Dr. David Church
Are you getting enough essential amino acids? Dr. David Church joins me to compare amino acid profiles and their impact on health.
When we look at the math behind protein quality, the differences between animal and plant sources are significant. In a trial he helped design, Dr. David Church matched a 4-ounce beef patty against a soy-based burger. He had to double the soy to roughly match the single beef patty in essential amino acids. The blood amino acid levels shocked him.
David joins me at Protein Summit 3.0 to explain what happened.
He also tells me why muscle protein breakdown is so much harder to measure than synthesis, and shares insights from his 21-day testosterone study, where the men on testosterone lost all of their weight as fat while the placebo group lost about half of theirs as fat-free mass.
Are you getting enough essential amino acids? Dr. David Church joins me to compare amino acid profiles and their impact on health.
When we look at the math behind protein quality, the differences between animal and plant sources are significant. In a trial he helped design, Dr. David Church matched a 4-ounce beef patty against a soy-based burger. He had to double the soy to roughly match the single beef patty in essential amino acids. The blood amino acid levels shocked him.
David joins me at Protein Summit 3.0 to explain what happened.
He also tells me why muscle protein breakdown is so much harder to measure than synthesis, and shares insights from his 21-day testosterone study, where the men on testosterone lost all of their weight as fat while the placebo group lost about half of theirs as fat-free mass.
What Testosterone, Burgers, and Legos Teach Us About Muscle
Muscle is the organ of longevity. It is your metabolic armor, the reservoir that protects you from chronic disease, and a primary driver of how well you age. Yet the way standard medicine measures and talks about muscle remains fundamentally broken. That is why I Read More...
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 00:00
For those who don’t know you, you are Dr. David Church. You are at Arkansas. You are well known in the field for many things: muscle, essential amino acids. And what’s so amazing is you’re younger than many of I. I say that we joke, but you know, in science, we’ve seen this kind of trajectory change. That they say that thoughts change one funeral at a time, which is so morbid. But you’re interested in a lot of the things that I think translate to today, both basic science, molecular science, and then these potential mechanisms and and how they translate over. You’ve published quite a bit, but one of the studies or the group of studies is the Nandoon. I would love for you to take us through a little bit about why. Why did you model these studies? Why did these things come about?
Dr. David Church 00:50
I got lucky on that study. I’ll be honest. I did my PhD with Dr. Jay Hoffman. He’s now he’s known the states. He’s he’s working in a lab in Israel, and he got a grant to do this. And he’s like, I’m going to do these these series of testosterone studies. What was interesting about Dr. Hoffman is he played in the NFL, and so he’s got that background from when testosterone. Yeah, testosterone was legal when he played as well. So a lot of the players got it then, and so he just always had a strong interest in it. And so, so his credit it was really his design, and he was a part of the Mitchell report when they investigated the Major League Baseball for all the steroid abuse, we’ve seen this in the previous rodent studies where they saw satellite cells, and like I said, they they did this. We he’s designed the study where there’s four groups of animals, and when they’re young, they either got treated with a placebo or nanolone decanate, and then we had another group that was older that were treated with either nandrolone or the or the decanate. We aged those young animals out for I think like eight months. What
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 01:42
would be the equivalent? It’s like
Dr. David Church 01:43
it’s like 32 years in a human, right? So it’s a very long time. It was one of those ones when I wrote the discussion of the paper. I was like, wait a minute, is that right? And you kind of have to double check it, and you’re like, wow. And so first off, you get a great appreciation for how good humans actually are at aging compared to mice, right? I think that’s an interesting point. There, we just set it up that way to go off the previous literature, but one of the kind of one of the thoughts you get from when you start looking at that is like, well, and I wouldn’t promote this, but I’ve I’ve said it before. It’s like, well, if you’re working with an athlete and the major sporting organizations are going to have sort of a tiered band system, where the first offense is 20 games or something, well, probably worth the 20 game suspension if it’s going to extrapolate out for 32 years in a human is a really interesting study that we thought had actually interesting ramifications, and I know that there are now human studies ongoing. I’m pretty sure the clinical trials got posted for one the other day that’s going to happen up in Canada where they’re going to try to replicate these effects we’ve seen in animals and humans. So it’d be really interesting. Obviously, we can’t age the human 32 years,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 02:39
and no one would want that,
Dr. David Church 02:40
right? No, I wouldn’t. I mean, I feel like some days age me 32 years in one day, but that data should be. It’ll probably take three or five years. You know, science does move, like you said, one funeral at a time. But it’ll be really interesting to see the results of the human trials and see how it relates to the animal studies. We really, honestly, got lucky that we happen to have a collaborator that basically was like, I got these studies going on. I designed them this way with the intent of like the sport angle, and also we’ve previously seen in the literature, and then for me to be like, well, I’ll send you some deuterium. So that’s the beautiful thing about the isotopes is like I was able to just send them some of this this fancy water, and he was just able to inject it, and they send the tissues back over, and yeah, the rest was sort of history on that. But it was a really fun study.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 03:17
We talk about hormones, hormone replacement a lot on on the the show prior to the testosterone anabolic, you know, there was anabolic ban, and it really changed the way people think about testosterone. But testosterone, measuring testosterone in men, is probably the number one biomarker that predicts their trajectory of life in blood sugar regulation, we know with low muscle mass, there’s issues with blood sugar regulation. Also, osteoporosis, there’s you know cholesterol metabolism. There’s all of these things that we see.
Dr. David Church 03:52
It’s a really interesting thing because we did do a human study. The lead on it was Alyssa Veronoski, and you got a feel for her because we did her PhDs together, and she thought she was escaping during postdoc and we postdoc together. Yeah, that’s kind of how science works, especially in our field because it’s quite small. We did this series, this study in humans at Pennyson Biomedical, and phase one we just measured like how they were coming in off the street, and this was geared towards more of a Department of Defense. It was a Department of Defense study, so it’s 1832 year old men, service age individuals, right? And so we bring them in. We assess them how they are during baseline, and then during this phase two is inpatient study. So they’re at Pennington Biomedical Research Center, and they’re in the metabolic ward, 24 hour supervision for 21 days. And we did a 55% energy deficit, which like that’s a lot. That’s a that’s a hefty one. Yeah, for the reviewers at home, like that’s a hefty one. Like GLP ones puts you at 18 to 39% based off the literature. I know some people go can probably get higher or lower, you know, but I mean they
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 04:47
would feel hungry. So the GLP ones
Dr. David Church 04:49
they’re not as hungry, right? Yeah, yeah.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 04:51
Meal suffering.
Dr. David Church 04:52
I get a little hangry if I skip lunch. You know what I mean? And it was diet and exercise induced. And then
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 04:56
oh, that’s yeah.
Dr. David Church 04:57
And then there was like I believe three nights of. Restriction. They only got four hours, and then the next two nights they got a full eight. So it’s about as much as we could do to beat some of these individuals. Not really beat them, but really try to beat up the physiology as much we could. What was interesting was the group that got testosterone uneducanate. So the very long, it’s a very long half life. Those individuals, they got slightly. Alyssa and I have this debate. She’s probably right because she usually is. So hopefully she hears that and that makes it into the podcast. But they got slightly over super physiological. I always say they’re like within, but they there’s a few of them. the The variance bar got above that magic number, but these are man sort of man made brackets,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 05:33
right?
Dr. David Church 05:33
And then the the placebo group, some of them got slightly hypogonadal, but they weren’t like extreme. They weren’t like total suppression, and it wasn’t like huge numbers, so it was pretty interesting because for them we kept them within sort of the upper and lower end of like physiological ranges. And to your point, where this rambling and yammering is going is the ones that were on the testosterone group, both groups lost the same amount of weight. The testosterone group it was now it was two compartment model, so the testosterone group lost at all its fat mass. The placebo group lost at 50% fat-free mass and 50% as fat mass. So it was just to your point. It’s really interesting how just something as simple as you know. I think testosterone in men. I think maybe iron in women. Some of these simple things we can measure in a clinic are really valuable.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 06:14
Potentially, you know, we’re still behind the eight ball on really studying androgens in women. I
Dr. David Church 06:19
agree. Yeah, yeah.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 06:20
But for men, there is a lot of research.
Dr. David Church 06:23
I agree, and even I have a good colleague at South Carolina, Katie Rose Hirsch, who’s doing urine and salivary hormone profile in women throughout different phases. Like that way, you can get it through every month. And every time I look at her data, where they get the progesterone, estrogen, estradiol, etc., it’s so fascinating because you don’t see this beautiful textbook cycle that they they taught me at
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 06:41
least it’s much more it’s
Dr. David Church 06:43
very complicated so it’s I think the the hormonal aspect in women it’s going to be really interesting the next five or 10 years to see what’s going to come out about that
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 06:51
and to your point women are very complicated at least that’s what my husband says they’re very complicated but men we really do have a good idea of where we want to see testosterone. Yes, there are testosterone receptors, CAG repeats. You know, we know that again, if you’re 300 or less,
Dr. David Church 07:09
yeah,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 07:10
you’re probably at risk.
Dr. David Church 07:11
Yeah, yeah,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 07:12
right. For men, were there other things that really stuck out to you? I know it was a while ago, but the the fact that those that were optimized, we’ll say optimized for testosterone. I know you said there were some that were slightly above physiologic, but again, all the weight that they lost was fat mass.
Dr. David Church 07:28
Yeah, I thought it was really interesting. I would like to keep doing more of the studies, obviously, because it’s a fun topic, right? I mean, it’s it’s pince the name Dr. Milehead, right? I think it’s an interesting topic. What I found interesting but also important was that we saw no differences on the performance.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 07:44
Yes, right,
Dr. David Church 07:45
and that’s key because body composition is important and it plays a role in sort of survival scenarios. Don’t do not, I do not want to underestimate that point. But at the end of the day, we didn’t see these changes in performance outcomes that would be analogous to military performance. Now it’s 21 days. You know, like maybe we need to go longer. Maybe we need more cycles of that stress. Because again, if you look at more of the real world impact environments, when special operation soldiers come over, they come back over. A lot of them are hypogonadal. You look at some of the ranger studies that have been done. They now that’s a very extreme stress. In fairness, but they do get hygienic
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 08:18
seal stress was more. But you know,
Dr. David Church 08:21
any of those, I would probably be ringing the bell earlier than I care to admit, to be honest with you. But yeah, they will. They will certainly argue amongst themselves. But I will tell you, as a physiologist, they are all pretty brutal stressors. My point, my the fundamental point, I guess I’m making jokes. Yeah, all the jokes aside, because they could all kick my booty. They all come back pretty pretty hypogonadal. And like I said in our study that we did this, where we did our best to simulate it in the lab, I think that’s the really interesting point.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 08:46
Four hours a night of sleep restriction. Yeah, it’s like we
Dr. David Church 08:49
still weren’t able to do it enough to get everyone consistently hypogonadal, right? So it’s really interesting.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 08:54
Yes, and also think about the metabolic ward. You’re probably not putting them in the on the floor, and there’s not you have the environmental factors yeah all this other stuff yeah
Dr. David Church 09:05
and the other thing that was really interesting about that story I don’t mean to to interrupt you there but or the that study was and I’m working on the data still so I apologize I I the lead author on that Stefan Pasiakos who’s also a genius but who’s
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 09:18
also will be here he’ll
Dr. David Church 09:19
be here at Protein Summit which is where we’re at, and it’s like the Oscars for protein and amino acids. It’s cool for me because I was a little either youngling or something when Protein Summit one and two came on. So to be invited to three is just I get goosebumps thinking about it. But Stephen’s a great mentor, and I need to get this paper out. We have some of these methodologies that allow us to sort of discern the rate of whole body protein breakdown, whole body, not muscle. So explain
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 09:43
to explain to the listener or viewer what.
Dr. David Church 09:45
Sure. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We use these fancy thing called isotopes, and for protein, I describe it as Legos because I have a four and a six year old, and I’m a four and a six year old to myself.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 09:53
Do you know I have a five and a six year old? I did
Dr. David Church 09:55
not know. And you know
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 09:56
that I’ve injured my feet so many times on those Legos. And every time I say don’t bring any Legos home, and guess what?
Dr. David Church 10:03
I keep buying them. But I like the Lego analogy because there’s all different shapes and sizes and colors, just like there’s all different types of amino acids that make the protein. So you can use all these Legos to make different structures. And one of the techniques we use a lot in our lab is called stable isotope tracers. And I know it’s been mentioned on the podcast before, but how I would describe is you have all these Legos, and we’ll take one of them. We’ll take a square four top red one, right? And some of those square four top red ones we’ll put like fluorescent paint on that you don’t see with the eye, and then we could build that Lego. But if you’re in the dark and you can’t see it, well, you turn the light on, you see this fluorescent dye in the light, and you could count how many dots of the fluorescence there is, and you could discern sort of the rate at which whatever we’re measuring. In this case, we’re measuring muscle protein synthesis sometimes, but in the case when I’m talking about the study, it’d be whole body protein breakdown. And what we actually look there is we look at how quickly that fluorescent label. Now, if it’s not a fluorescent label, it’s the heavy version of the isotope.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 10:56
And also, before you get into this, because we’ve had people talk about tracers, but what we haven’t really had people discuss is muscle protein breakdown versus muscle protein synthesis.
Speaker 3 11:09
Yes,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 11:09
because we always talk about muscle protein synthesis, which is easier to measure, why we would measure one or the other, where we’re limited.
Dr. David Church 11:16
Yeah, that’s a great question. I mean, I’ve spent six years thinking about it, I mean, longer than that, but six years really trying to get this muscle protein breakdown thing. And the reason I say this, that’s the harder one to measure.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 11:27
That’s right. It
Dr. David Church 11:28
is harder. We can do it. There’s things like d3 methylation, which will measure myofibular of the whole body. But we sometimes want like a compartment for that
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 11:37
myofibular is
Dr. David Church 11:38
a whole every yeah. It’s the contractile units of a muscle, and we do it in the urine. So the point is, is we’re getting all the myofibular breakdown of all the muscle in the body. Whereas with muscle protein synthesis, we’re measuring the synthesis of one muscle, and we really want to measure it in the same compartment so we compare apples to apples, not apples to oranges. And you know, I mean, I don’t think he was the only one to do it. Like Bob, Mike Rennie, a lot of the early protein researchers, Arnie Ferrando, etc. They would do what’s called a three-pole model. Not many places can do them anymore, but you have a femoral arterial line, so you can imagine why. If you’re in a hospital, it’s they’ll get an anesthesiologist or something, and it’s no big deal. Those they put lines in in their sleep, but it’s very invasive. And if you have an issue go wrong, you now have an arterial line that’s open, and it just it can keep going, but they have an arterial line, they have a venous line, and they’ll take biopsy. So with that, you kind of get all sides of the equation: what’s going in, what’s coming out, what’s going on inside. That was a really great way that you could do synthesis and breakdown at the same time. We’ve kind of lost that technique, and we can do synthesis quite well, and that’s why all the studies are usually muscle protein synthesis, myself included. We can do breakdown in a muscle protein breakdown in a sort of unstimulated state. So if the testosterone work, we can do it, and we actually did it in that study where we measured muscle protein synthesis and muscle protein breakdown in the same tissue at the same time because testosterone works in the basal slash unfed unstimulated state,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 12:59
as opposed to
Dr. David Church 13:00
if you feed. So as soon as you feed, now we have what’s called a non-steady state.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 13:04
Which, by the way, I don’t want to necessarily say this out loud, but one way that we see that patients push down their testosterone is they eat before the lab test.
Dr. David Church 13:16
Oh, interesting. I’ve heard a lot of the tricks, like if you don’t sleep for 24 hours, it’ll suppress the the axis pretty quickly.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 13:23
That makes perfect sense. What you’re saying is that testosterone only works from a muscle protein synthesis response in the fasted state, or that the blood levels even. It
Dr. David Church 13:35
actually go back to some of the original studies where Arnie Frando actually is the one that sorted this out. We got to actually break down the cycle. What’s going on with muscle protein turnover? So let’s think of that Lego block again, right? Let’s say we built a castle, right? We built our little Lego castle, and then you come in and you step on it, right? Because it got left in the middle of the room, right? And those Lego blocks fall off the castle, but it’s still on the carpet, or you have like a rug. It’s still on the rug. The castle’s been broken down, but the the Lego block has not left the rug. It’s still in the muscle cell, is what I’m saying. So you you’ll have breakdown where an amino acid has left a protein, but the amino acid has not then gone outside of the cell and back into the bloodstream. What testosterone does, and I would my assumption as in there’s some data to support this, but we don’t really know, which is weird.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 14:19
I know, right?
Dr. David Church 14:20
It’s really interesting. I think it makes protein synthesis more energy efficient. So instead of that amino acid effluxing, aka leaving the muscle cell, it’s recycled back into new proteins, into muscle proteins.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 14:31
Right, that’s how testosterone
Dr. David Church 14:33
works, actually, for muscles. So we can measure that in the basal state quite well, and that’s exactly what we saw in those that that experiment I was mentioning earlier, where those that got testosterone after we did the the 21 days have really sort of beating them up. They had improved muscle net balance because of a reduction in muscle protein breakdown. Nothing to do with synthesis, but it’s really a better recycling of the amino acid so that doesn’t leave the muscle cell.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 14:57
Wow!
Dr. David Church 14:58
Yeah, so that’s what’s going on there because. Testosterone works that way. It works well to measure it. That so, if you had two clinical states, individuals with obesity, individuals not, you can measure muscle protein synthesis and breakdown in sort of a basal state overnight. It’s just once you then go to feed them, which is usually what we’re interested in, because that’s where we find sort of anabolic resistance in older adults is due to feeding. Then we get this non-steady state because we just dropped a large bolus of Lego blocks onto the carpet, and it’s got to go somewhere, right? Then it gets very difficult to measure muscle protein breakdown because we’re violating a lot of the assumptions through which we model this data. If you have that nice three pull model and you can take the arterial lines and stuff, you can do it. But most of us don’t. But there are a lot of us that are thinking about it and trying to find ways to do it, and you know we might just have to do it over longer period of time, or you know, there’s there’s some people have used the de-rated water technique to load up, and then they stop having individuals drink that water, and then over the course of two weeks, you can measure muscle protein breakdown. But then, how are you measuring synthesis over the two weeks, right? So it’s an interesting challenge, but I think we’ll find a solution to it eventually, right?
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 16:01
And the clinical outcome would be net muscle.
Dr. David Church 16:05
Yeah, and that I’m glad you bring that up because that’s the actual anabolic response.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 16:09
Right.
Dr. David Church 16:09
Net muscle protein balance is actually anabolic. If it’s positive, you’re in an anabolic state. For young, healthy individuals, 18 to 30 year old individuals, we’re probably fine measuring synthesis. It seems to be the overriding response. But
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 16:22
would you say it’s a proxy for? I’ve always described it, and I’d love to be corrected. A proxy for muscle health, muscle that is doing what it’s supposed. I think that’s a
Dr. David Church 16:33
fair point. I really do. I’ve said the same because when you’re measuring protein synthesis, you are measuring protein turnover. That protein turnover is indicative of muscle health, right? If it’s altered to some degree, that’s not good. Maybe it’s altered because you have aggregates in the muscle and or aging. Yeah, which yes, exactly. Or you know, in burns, it’s quite interesting because it can go either way. That’s important for the
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 16:56
accelerate in burns. In burns,
Dr. David Church 16:57
it accelerates because you have a hypermetabolic state, and so synthesis is actually two times as high in burn patients as non-burn, which is why they need
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 17:05
dietary protein.
Dr. David Church 17:06
Right. The breakdown is elevated threefold. So it’s the most catabolic state we’ve ever measured is actually burns, but
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 17:13
not cachexia.
Dr. David Church 17:14
It’s it’s burns by far.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 17:16
Wow.
Dr. David Church 17:16
Burns. It’s a very very catabolic state. Cachexia is not far behind. That’s no bueno either. That’s why it’s important. If you only measured one side of the equation, you see, oh man, they’re really they have a really high synthesis rate.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 17:27
That’s smart.
Dr. David Church 17:28
But if you measure the breakdown right now, you see they’re in a very catabolic state. But like young, healthy individuals, and maybe even healthy older adults, we’re probably okay with just synthesis. That’s probably telling us where we’re at. But it’s definitely a marker of I would say muscle protein turnover, muscle remodeling, and that would be definitely if you don’t have that response, we certainly don’t have good muscle health.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 17:47
Do you think there is something else that one could be measuring? Because in science, a lot of times we ask the same, we use the tools that we have to answer different questions, but we look at it through the lens of say muscle protein synthesis. Do you think that there’s another marker or proxy marker that we’re missing?
Dr. David Church 18:06
I think a lot of us are trying to figure out the muscle protein breakdown thing in sort of clinical paradigms. I still think whole body protein balance is important. Muscle is crucial, but if you don’t satisfy the whole body, it’s going to be hard to feed the muscle. Right, your liver, the brain, the heart, the lungs, for better or worse, these organs have to be fed. Then the muscle sort of gets fed. It’s not exactly like that, but that is sort of yeah, right. I mean, there’s a reason. So I still think whole body protein balance is very important, particularly if you start getting in clinical states. Even you know individuals with some sort of glucose dysregulation, we do not. How
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 18:38
would that impact whole body protein balance?
Dr. David Church 18:42
Yeah. So in most of our clinical scenarios, we’ll see that typically breakdown is elevated. Synthesis is not always necessarily affected, but breakdown will be elevated, and therefore they’re in a less either they are in a negative net balance or they’re in a less positive net balance in sort of age matched healthy controls. Would that be
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 18:59
disease? Would that be certain diseases like type two diabetes, something like that.
Dr. David Church 19:03
Yeah, we even see it in obesity. I was gonna ask. Yeah, yeah. So actually, not to keep pivoting here, but even at the muscle level, and Bettina Mettendorfer has great work. So I trained
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 19:12
with Bettina. Did you know that? They did not. I did not. My
Dr. David Church 19:15
wife is my wife is a graduate of Washu. She’s the smart one. Yes, I am not. So then you should know, right? The the the individuals with obesity, they have anabolic resistance in the muscle.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 19:25
Doesn’t matter the age.
Dr. David Church 19:26
No, and then if they lose, it was a 10 or 15% of body weight. I think is what she does as that model. Then the anabolic response is restored. So it doesn’t have to be cachexia to have a negative impact on these you know protein synthesis and breakdown. It it’s quite interesting how like even things of that we think is normal for better worse. I don’t want to like say
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 19:45
what what do you mean like like
Dr. David Church 19:47
so I’m in Arkansas and sometimes when we talk to people about oh diabetes and obesity in Arkansas, it’s quite interesting that the you know they might say well I have diabetes and it’s not seen as like the same as like like if you were to tell someone they have cancer and I. That they’re very different things, but it’s quite interesting how we don’t always jump to being as concerned about getting a type two diabetes sort of. It’s
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 20:09
a good point.
Dr. David Church 20:10
Generally speaking, obviously there’s a there’s a distribution of the bell curve. Some people take it very seriously, and some probably don’t.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 20:15
Weight loss and body composition improvement likely affects both.
Dr. David Church 20:19
Yeah, one of the biggest risk factors for cancer is obesity, so it’s quite interesting how we view it. And so I just think it’s important to highlight that we don’t have to be talking about burn children, right? We don’t have to be talking about someone with cancer cachexia. We’re talking about something that really affects a large portion of our population, and therefore we see it a lot in our lives where we can have alterations in these, you know, protein synthesis or protein breakdown.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 20:42
And would you say, if we think about that in translation to the everyday person, that if someone is struggling with obesity, that they would, again, I’m just making kind of a jump here, that they would be better off having a higher protein diet, assuming calories are controlled because of, say, anabolic resistance in the muscle.
Dr. David Church 21:05
We do. I mean, there’s there’s good work supporting at least 1.2 grams per kilogram per day, helping with weight loss and weight maintenance. When, like you said, calories, etc., all that are are controlled in these. The OptiMin trial. Now it’s men. I understand that, but it’s older adults that were frail, and actually was a testosterone study. So zero, they did the RDA 0.8, 1.2, and then there’s a subset there with like added testosterone or not. And this was a semi-controlled feeding study, as in the food was provided to these individuals for six months. I’ve done seven-day feeding studies in the lab where we weigh the food in and out, and just seven days is brutal. I know it sounds so trivial because many of the listeners like, well, I feed a household for seven days a week. I’m like, I I understand that. Measuring everything
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 21:48
and packing it.
Dr. David Church 21:49
I mean, we have great participants, so I can’t complain at all. But it’s it’s hard. It’s hard. It’s hard to feed people that because you’re usually on a limited menu. I’m just trying to give people some insight. Like you’re doing your best, but there’s a limited menu. So anyone that you see that’s done a three or six months feeding trial, for me, it’s an automatic tip of the hat, regardless of what the results say.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 22:08
It’s good perspective for people that are not in the lab right now. There’s a ton of influx of information because of AI, and there’s still a very small percentage of people that are doing feeding studies, and so if someone is getting a Google alert and a study comes out, and maybe the criticism is, but it was only seven days or it was only four weeks, it is so difficult to do these studies and to do it well. When the testosterone, so would you say you were saying?
Dr. David Church 22:37
Oh, I was talking about that Opti. You asked me about the weight loss. I apologize. Yeah,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 22:41
catabolk resistance muscle. So they did
Dr. David Church 22:43
six months of that, and even in that study, where is pretty much semi-controlled, where they gave them food for six months, the group that got 1.2 lost more fat mass than the group that got point eight, and we see that effect very consistently. I was going to say, is
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 22:55
it fair to say that 1.2 from a body composition perspective is always better than point eight.
Dr. David Church 23:01
Of everything with protein, has the most evidence.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 23:04
I would agree
Dr. David Church 23:05
that is it’s not even maybe muscle protein synthesis because everyone like rolls their eyes. But there’s nothing else. There’s not. Yeah.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 23:11
So if we don’t talk about muscle protein synthesis from some kind of endpoint that we’re measuring, DEXA changes are too small. If you’re thinking about sarcopenia, yeah, muscle changes. If you’re going to lose 8% of your muscle weight in 10 years, how are you going to see that at a?
Dr. David Church 23:26
I say this all the time. Three
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 23:28
month study.
Dr. David Church 23:28
I agree 100% because there’s this rush to like hard endpoints, hard endpoints. I agree when possible, but on muscle, the beauty of muscle. I’m getting goosebumps as I say this. Right, 2006 underappreciated rule of muscle disease.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 23:39
The best Bob Wolf paper. You guys got to
Dr. David Church 23:41
read it, please. I read it 100. Literally goosebumps. It’s coming. I promise you. You’re really nerds. You know. Yeah. The beauty of muscle is that it it buffers the stress, and it’ll do it for a long time. Warsaw ghetto studies. Unbelievable. Belfast starvation studies. The muscle will maintain plasma amino acid concentrations until the organism dies.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 23:59
Unbelievable.
Dr. David Church 23:59
So you’re going to capture that in a three to six month trial, you’re not. So that’s where the kinetics, the muscle protein synthesis dork stuff, is important. But again, back to your point, I do think I’m not a weight maintenance weight loss expert. Clearly, it’s not my bag. But my understanding of what I know about the literature is that the 1.2 mark is very well supported in that literature. And it seems like now I’ve started to look for it. By the way, when I see a study at that, I’m like, oh, they measured weight loss, which is how I knew about the OptiMen study because I just saw it two weeks ago and I looked and I was like, oh, interesting. Like they saw a significant difference for fat mass. It is a very consistent thing when you look. A little bit higher protein intake, it will cause a little bit greater fat mass loss when calories are consistent. So it seems to be a pretty good strategy.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 24:38
If we think about testosterone, sometimes shows improvements, and then sometimes it doesn’t show performance improvements.
Dr. David Church 24:46
To be fair, though, that was a six-month study, and like the one I previously done was 21 days. So that’s a good point. And older adult versus younger,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 24:53
yeah, which would, in my mind, as a clinician, mean that hormonal status for an older person plus. Nutrition seems to be extremely important.
Dr. David Church 25:03
Well, yeah, because they in this case, and again, Arnie Frando did a lot of this work. They work through different mechanisms, right? I already talked about the testosterone. Whereas if you feed amino acids, whether it’s dietary protein or however you want to take them in,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 25:15
essential amino, yeah,
Dr. David Church 25:16
any of them, yeah, that stimulates muscle protein synthesis. So they work through different mechanisms, so they’re very complementary. It’s if you have an individual, you know, that is an older adult and they are hypogonadal. I know it depends on the clinician, and not all clinicians will prescribe purely based off blood levels. But you got to have the symptomology as well.
Speaker 4 25:34
Right.
Dr. David Church 25:34
But if you and so if you have the symptomology and the and blood concentrations are low, yeah, I mean it seems to be a really effective strategy to improve physical function, lean math. Church,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 25:42
that’s very well read of you for being a PhD. That’s exactly right.
Dr. David Church 25:47
Yeah, well, it helps when the guy that you studied under for eight years published most of those papers. Yeah, it was one of those things that going into the postdoc, despite having a PhD in what I thought was a good muscle background, I actually didn’t have a good apprenticeship about the different mechanisms through which those two work, but that’s why they work so so they can work synergistically.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 26:04
And basically, what you’re saying is that the balance between hormones and nutrition, all of it changes for outcomes for muscle health,
Dr. David Church 26:12
right?
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 26:12
And you have to push different levers at different times,
Dr. David Church 26:15
right?
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 26:15
What about nandrolone? You were saying you were mentioning this is of interest to me, the idea of the androgen effect, so you could call androgens overall, the effect on satellite cells, the effect on muscle memory. Can you explain some of those findings, and or just the background?
Dr. David Church 26:34
We have done work in mice with nandrolone. One was a very simple sort of overtraining study where we really stressed these mice and those that got the nangeloon to no surprise handled the stress better. The more interesting thing is probably the muscle memory effect. Whereas I think you go back all the way to 2001. I think it’s a journal physiology paper in 2001. They had pellets. They did testosterone pellets in the mice versus not, and they had them on the the testo, and then and then they dropped it off, and then they they aged them for I think six weeks, something along those lines. But they aged them for a period of time. How do
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 27:04
you age mice? What’s the aging?
Dr. David Church 27:06
Well, you just let them age.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 27:08
Oh, that’s it. There’s nothing.
Dr. David Church 27:09
Well, I think they keep them like you know, it’s pretty standard
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 27:12
with their mother-in-law.
Dr. David Church 27:12
Again, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Disclaimer: Okay, not an animal researcher. I get tissue nowadays, and I’ll run the animal tissue. But I, in fairness, they’re very good research usually. So I think they they kind of like set the cage standards. They feed them a set amount, etc. But in this case, they aged the two sets of mice, and those they got, and then they trained them six weeks later, something like that, some set amount of time later.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 27:32
And they stopped the androgen.
Dr. David Church 27:34
Yeah, and the androgens were no longer working at this point. Thank you for making sure that’s clear. And the animals that had gotten the testosterone earlier in life, had greater muscle mass in response to the exercise training. They had greater muscle mass. They had greater satellite cell content, and they had greater. I forget how they measured function in that study. Might have been grip strength, which is common in mice, but they had greater some sort of strength as well in those mice. It
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 27:53
had more satellite cells, and satellite cells I I think of as the the cells that feed the muscle, or like the stem side. They help with
Dr. David Church 28:00
repair of the muscle during damage. Yeah, yeah, stem cells. And Chris Fry and John McCarthy and that group at Kentucky are really world leaders in this. I am not, and so they would probably say, “Oh, we really know how they work really well.” But I look at some of the work they do, and I’m like, “Well, it does this, it does that,” and I’m just not. Char Peterson has a study with testosterone showing it’s not satellite cell mediated, right? So I was talking to Chris Rye actually, I think almost two years about this this study where we gave testosterone, we aged them, and we did the muscle protein synthesis stuff and everything. He was like, I I wonder if it’s a satellite cell thing, blah blah. And then we were like talking later on, and then and then he actually on the call had brought up like, actually no, Dr. Dr. Charlotte Peterson, who’s a legend for those of you that don’t know, was like they’re like actually her show they showed that testosterone doesn’t get mediated through satellite cells, so it’s a really
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 28:48
what do you think?
Dr. David Church 28:49
I don’t know. Testosterone is a very powerful tool, so I’d be shocked if it’s one thing, right? It’s a physiological system. There’s probably epigenetic changes, right, that are going on.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 29:01
What about the muscle memory? From muscle memory, from my understanding, is more neurological.
Dr. David Church 29:06
So we do see there are studies that help support that that motor neuron is thicker and that the the myelination stronger. There’s some epigenetic markers. But
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 29:14
what do we think about what is the correct terminology for you know how people they’ll train when they’re younger, then they let it go, or they I don’t know have kids that leave Legos around.
Dr. David Church 29:26
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 29:26
But then they go back to the gym.
Dr. David Church 29:27
Research is me, search is what I call that. Yeah, and then they go back
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 29:30
to the gym, and all of a sudden they’re fit again.
Dr. David Church 29:32
Yeah, I mean sometimes
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 29:33
we think of that as muscle memory too. In the and I think that is population. I
Dr. David Church 29:36
think that is to a certain extent. I think like there’s certainly a motor control aspect there, right? You’ve been there. You’ve sort of done that. I hate to say it that way, but
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 29:45
so you get better at the movement pattern, right?
Dr. David Church 29:47
Yeah, I mean you’ve you’ve done it before. It’s like I know for me, you know, again, research is me search. I had two kids, and I spent a lot of time with them that first year, and then kind of you know I say training, but not like you do when you don’t have kids. By the way, to be clear to anyone that’s wondering. But then you go. They’ll
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 30:00
never understand that statement until they have children.
Dr. David Church 30:02
I didn’t. I didn’t. I had two dogs, and I was like, and it’s a good prep, but it’s not quite the same. But even myself, it’s one of those things that was like, oh man, I got back sorted up to my numbers really quickly. You know what I mean? So I, I think there has to be an epigenetic component to it, and it’s not happening just in the muscle. To your point, I mean that M1 motor unit in the brain. That’s a very powerful point, right? If we stimulate that with a TMS signal, we can actually increase
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 30:26
transmit for the listening. Yeah, the transmagnetic stimulation.
Dr. David Church 30:29
I’m glad you do this. Yeah, if you stimulate that point with the TMS, like you said, even acutely, you can increase force production. In a video, like just right now, if you were to take me from here, stimulate that spot, I would produce more force. So there’s probably these epigenetic changes that occur throughout the body that help lead to like, well, we’ve done this before. We want to be ready for it if it happened again. I mean, that’d probably be a pretty good thing if that was baked into into our sort of operating system.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 30:52
And maybe we weren’t designed to have low hormonal status when we’re young. Do you think that training offsets the hormone status, for example, if someone was essentially hypogonadal in any capacity. I
Dr. David Church 31:05
think the best data, in fairness, that we have, and actually I believe it’s Luke or Stu. Again, more legends of the field. They have done androgen deprivation therapy in prostate cancer patients, and they did resistance exercise with 25 grams of whey protein. They found that those those men with androgen deprivation therapy, and it really is. There’s debate about whether or not that’s the right task, and that’s irrelevant for this conversation. What’s relevant is the science and the people they got were on ADT.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 31:30
You know that they don’t really do that anymore, depending on the kind of prostate cancer.
Dr. David Church 31:33
Yeah, that’s why I was saying do
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 31:35
androgen deprivation therapy.
Dr. David Church 31:36
I played around with doing some of that work early at UAMS, and so I loosely know some of this stuff, but yeah, I do know they have this study. And again, that this was
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 31:44
fascinating for the listener. Basically, there was this belief that testosterone caused prostate cancer.
Dr. David Church 31:50
Right.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 31:51
Then they castrated everybody, and you know, it turned out to be one study, one participant.
Dr. David Church 31:55
Interesting.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 31:56
With a blood marker they don’t use anymore.
Dr. David Church 31:58
Interesting. I did not know that.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 32:00
And that spawned the whole thought
Dr. David Church 32:02
process. Ah, interesting.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 32:04
For decades, they were castration. This is why,
Dr. David Church 32:06
come on, learn.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 32:07
Now we know that depending on the kind of prostate cancer, it’s a risk to have low testosterone.
Dr. David Church 32:11
Fascinating. And then, so I do know, like I said, in those those individuals that were in androgen deprivation therapy, they did do resistance exercise and 25 grams of whey protein post exercise, and they were able to get a response out of them. So it does appear that proper nutrition exercise can outweigh even something as as as strong as androgen deprivation therapy. Which that’s why I love exercise. It’s such a powerful thing, such
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 32:33
a stimulus.
Dr. David Church 32:34
And that’s why my again we’re talking about classics here. And I know he’s here. I saw my sugar sand in the lobby stew’s paper from 98, right? Where if you stimulate just one bout of resistance exercise, the muscle is primed to take up dietary protein for 48 hours. It’s just the coolest thing. I just love that study.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 32:50
So you did the beef patty study, which again I would love for you to talk about it because the question that you asked was whether plant based meat was equivalent to beef again. This is seems to be very contentious for whatever reason.
Dr. David Church 33:05
Yeah, it doesn’t need to be. I grew up on a soy and cornfield.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 33:07
Where did you grow up?
Dr. David Church 33:08
A small in Indiana, an Amish country, in western Putnam County, Indiana. Beyond that, 30 minutes from a Walmart, literally a gravel road out in the middle of nowhere, a soy and cornfield. So it was great. I’m sort of proud of that study because Bob had come. He’s like, “Oh, we’re gonna do Bob Wolf. Sorry, we’re gonna. He wanted to compare the the plant-based meat alternative, which is a soy-based burger and a ground beef burger. We did four ounces because that’s you know quarter pounder standard serving size. At the time that the grant was written, the plant-based meat alternative, the soy burger said 19 grams of protein. A USDA will list four ounces of beef as 19 grams of protein. And our fundamental premise was like the beef has more essential amino acids, and therefore, if we get more out there, greater muscle protein synthesis. I was trying to do some math because you, it’s very hard to find amino acid composition of many things, but of these new products, understandably so. Most of the soy-based meat alternative burger is soy protein concentrate. So I was doing some back of the napkin math, and I was like, “Oh, wait a minute! If this is 19 grams of protein, then it’s like four and a half grams of EA, and the burger is 19 grams and like 8.9 grams of EA.” I go, “If we do a double soy burger comparison, we’ll have an iso-nitrogenous and an isoea. That’s what I was interested in.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 34:25
An iso-nitrogenous and iso-e. So
Dr. David Church 34:27
iso protein.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 34:28
Yes,
Dr. David Church 34:29
based off 19 grams and a four-ounce beef patty and 19 grams and a a four-ounce soy patty and then iso essential amino acid because there’s 8.9 essential amino acids in the four-ounce beef burger and there would have been like nine ish grams in the in the double the eight ounce eight ounces soy and so in my head I’m like this is what I cared about and so I like I sent an email I was like this what we should do and I got the green light from Bob it’s like one of the first green lights I got because pretty much everything I’d said to that point he’s like yeah we did that in 1983 you know I wasn’t born then so it’s been a bit. So that I got the green light on, and then you like go and you do the you do the study, and by the was 18 to 30 year olds, you know, generally healthy individuals, normal BMI, which is how you sort of do some of these studies. And we did whole body protein synthesis and muscle protein synthesis and the plasma EAs, as I had predicted for once, the second time I should say in my career that you got the sort of essential amino acid profile that was the plasma essential amino acid profile after eating them, it was much higher in the in the four ounces of beef than it was in the four ounces of soy. But what I didn’t expect was in the eight ounces of soy was that the plasma essential amino acids never really got above the four ounces of beef.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 35:35
That’s a big statement.
Dr. David Church 35:36
It is. I was shocked. I was fundamentally shocked because you know you
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 35:40
gloss over that.
Dr. David Church 35:41
Yeah, soy protein. I would actually argue is a pretty high quality protein. I mean, there’s a reason. It’s a reason it is always used as the comparator. If you do anything else as a plant alternative, it’s kind of like well, you would get critiqued by the dorks and myself included.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 35:56
I was just thinking, I’m a, I’m
Dr. David Church 35:57
a, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I would have critiqued. I’m like, well, why didn’t you use soy, right? So it is as good as it’s going to get in that regard. So I was kind of shocked by that. So I don’t think it’s the soy protein concentrate itself. I think it’s probably more the binders. Maybe use that. I am not a food scientist expert, but they have to use some of these binders to keep the the product together.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 36:15
I don’t think that was in the paper.
Dr. David Church 36:16
That’s pure speculation you’re getting after the notes. You know, I didn’t have like some sort of citation for that. It’s just this just sort of hypothesis I have in my head because the soy protein concentrate on its own, if you look at the literature, it’ll get out there. It should get out there. It should be robust response. Yeah, yeah. And so I think it has very little to do with soy protein concentrate itself. But
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 36:38
but but hold on. As someone who cares about patient outcomes and health, what we would hear out there is that if you have enough plant protein, that will equal the same amount as an animal protein. But
Dr. David Church 36:54
so that is actually a valid point because we did we did
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 36:57
double
Dr. David Church 36:57
it comes with more calories.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 36:59
But but also if someone is eating something like the Impossible Burger, and they’re like, you know what? I recognize that soy protein. I mean, should be close, but I’m going to double it up.
Dr. David Church 37:10
Yeah,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 37:11
they double it up. They have double the calories fine. I don’t even care about the calories, but because of the binders, yeah, it never reaches blood levels of the amino acids in the appropriate way. Never stimulates muscle. But what’s
Dr. David Church 37:22
interesting is it did stimulate whole body protein synthesis.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 37:26
Not make sense of that for me.
Dr. David Church 37:27
Yeah, well, I mean, it might be a total nitrogen and calorie load thing there that we did put in the paper.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 37:31
A nitrogen for people listening is
Dr. David Church 37:33
protein.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 37:34
Protein. Roger, that
Dr. David Church 37:35
might be a total protein or total calorie thing. And in fairness to what we should have talked about, I start off with the plasma EADs because I’m working through the paper in my head, right? But the the big thing was the muscle protein synthetic response rate was that in the four ounce beef group it was significantly higher than the four ounce of a soy based meat alternative. And although it wasn’t statistically different than an eight ounce soy patty, it was three
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 37:55
ounces of that.
Dr. David Church 37:56
No, I know it was quantitatively higher still, which I found interesting. But the thing I cared the most about was that I replicated a previous paper from 2020, where if you looked at the Cmax, the maximal concentration of essential amino acids in the blood, it correlated quite strongly to the muscle protein synthesis rate. So that would tell us that it’s something about the essential amino acids are getting out in the blood to a better degree, which we solve from the curve, the nice plasminier curve over time, they get out to a better degree in the beef burger than the soy-based burgers, and that’s what’s key for stimulated muscle protein synthesis.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 38:31
This is a conversation that Arne Astrup would probably love. The legend, the guy who discovered anything discovered GLP-1, right?
Dr. David Church 38:41
Yeah, yeah.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 38:41
Connection in 1996 because it’s the quality, it’s the food matrix, and we don’t necessarily know what the binders do.
Dr. David Church 38:50
It’s like a molecular glue, yeah. And so when I’m writing the paper, you know, like again, I hope you guys appreciate sort of the openness here, but like when you’re writing the paper, you’re trying to make sense of like, well, the essential amino acids didn’t really get out there to the same degree, but we did stimulate muscle protein synthesis, which actually matters more.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 39:05
I feel that it it does,
Dr. David Church 39:07
and we did stimulate whole body protein balance, which does matter more in the plasma EAs. But when you’re looking at that plasma EA graph, you’re like, man, I really wonder what’s going on. And so you you know you’re looking at the literature, looking at PubMed. Nowadays they probably rip through AI because it’s faster looking than I am. But I was looking through PubMed, you know, and the only thing I could really kind of come to, because again, soy protein concentrate profile curves. If you get a drink of soy protein concentrate, you get nice elevations. There’s got to be something about the way that that patty is made, the food matrix. To your point, that is not letting the EAs get out there to a greater degree.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 39:38
I was convinced for the longest time, until Stu started publishing his work, that you could not stimulate muscle the same way with a plant protein than with an animal-based protein. And I thought for sure that it was the food matrix components like and serine, taurine, and creatine. But but I’m wrong. I mean, it’s
Dr. David Church 39:59
you can.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 40:00
Seems that you can,
Dr. David Church 40:01
if you can get the essential amino acids high enough. You know, I mean, in fairness, this too. I mean, he’s very, he’s very good. He’s one of the best. There’s no doubt about that. But I think he’d tell you the same thing. You have to take in more, right? You got to either get in more leucine, more whatever proxy you want to use. So it can be done. And again, if you’re 18 to 30, what if you’re
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 40:18
not? What if you’re what if you’re 45 and I’m GLP-1,
Dr. David Church 40:21
but you hear an older adult, which we see older, yeah, 65 and up, and we see that those individuals have a delayed or not delayed, sorry, reduced appetite. It’s under 20%. Well, now we have a reduced. It’s almost like a GLP-1 patient or an individual taking GLP-1. As soon as you get a reduced appetite, like it’s just going to be hard to do. You’re going to need some sort of
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 40:41
essential amino amino
Dr. David Church 40:42
acid, yeah, or you can do it through a supplement. So we do have some individuals I know that are plant based, and like, well, I want to do this, and how can I do it?
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 40:48
What do you recommend? I
Dr. David Church 40:49
give them, I make them go to essential, not make them, I suggest an essential amino acid supplement because at that point, you know, I’m
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 40:55
gonna send you some. We use Body Health Perfect Amino.
Dr. David Church 40:57
That’s yeah, that’s. Do you ever
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 40:58
use them?
Dr. David Church 40:59
I have not. I
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 41:00
am going to send you the best care package ever. And the reason I started using Perfect Amino is because of the use of GLP ones. Right. There were like Sixenda. There were all these other medications that were not as effective. And all of a sudden, GLP ones became available.
Dr. David Church 41:16
Yeah.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 41:17
And the loss of tissue.
Dr. David Church 41:20
It’s interesting, yeah.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 41:21
People were not interested for whatever reason. It seemed like they self-selected to carbohydrates. It is
Dr. David Church 41:27
interesting. So we have a couple trials going on on individuals taking GLP-1 now, and like the stories are all over the map. Like you got to feel for these people that do these studies for us. Like you know, we feed them, you know, for a couple days. We tell them to come in on overnight fast, and they’re stuck with me for 13 hours in a lab. It’s not as fun. No, it’s not. No, no, no, no, no. Usually run. In fairness, it’s usually not me they’re dealing with nowadays. I’m an old fuddy professor. It seems like you know they’re stuck with us for 13 hours. But the beautiful thing of that is you get some interesting stories. And so what I’ve almost pulled out of this more than anything than the data. I know it sounds bad on a show about science was the stories, you know.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 42:02
We’re storytelling.
Dr. David Church 42:03
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. It’s interesting. Where like some are just hyper responders, some don’t. This one lady, I’m like, can you just eat the protein? Yes, hyper
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 42:09
responders to what? To GLP one. Yes,
Dr. David Church 42:11
yes. And they’re back in their dose. Like this one was don’t
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 42:14
know why.
Dr. David Church 42:14
Yeah, and she’s just pushing the food. It was like watching my four year old just play with the food on his plate. Like she just she couldn’t like eat it as a kid. She’s like I can’t, and it’s just like this mind blowing thing, especially for a guy like me that loves to eat. That’s why I work out. It’s not that much, you know. They they really can’t, and so that’s that was like an interesting story. How
Speaker 5 42:32
old?
Dr. David Church 42:33
They’re 45 to 65. But that is the
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 42:36
point. That’s very risky. Listen, we don’t have a ton of great data on people that have been lifelong athletes in terms of what they’ve been doing.
Dr. David Church 42:43
Right.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 42:43
I mean, we get survey data of what they tell us, but you know, we’re not studying these people in you know how much are you walking. We’re not tracking them. I mean, maybe we will now with all of this stuff. But you put a 45 plus woman on a GLP-1 who’s a hyper responder, and she’s not eating.
Dr. David Church 43:02
Yeah, it was quite interesting because
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 43:04
hard to recover that.
Dr. David Church 43:05
To her credit, she stayed enrolled in the study. She’s going to go off it, and I’ll never forget. It’s a little bit of self depreciation. But I was like, well, if you don’t mind me asking, why are you going to go off? And she’s like, well, I’ve just lost so much weight that when I look in the mirror, I don’t see myself, you know. And I was like, no, I don’t know. Like I don’t have that problem, you know. But it’s just really interesting. And then you see other people that go on and they don’t lose anything. It’s really a
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 43:28
few pieces. I don’t know what to make of it. It’s
Dr. David Church 43:30
a header. It’s a really everyone thinks that like someone on a GLP one is someone on a GLP one. And I thought that too going into these studies. And boy, it has been like a watershed moment to see all these different stories come through the lab. It really is the art of of clinical care that you all are having to to intersect at the moment.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 43:46
Are you feeding them essentials?
Dr. David Church 43:48
At this moment, we’re trying. That’s the interesting is we’re trying to do through whole food and just feed them the RDA O 08.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 43:55
Here’s what I found so hard practicing clinician
Speaker 3 43:57
interesting
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 43:58
for these women particularly that are 45 plus on GLP ones. That is why I started using essential amino acids.
Dr. David Church 44:06
Yeah,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 44:06
especially for that reason, they seem to have an aversion to food, to whole foods.
Dr. David Church 44:12
Well, we have put that in as a large grant. We keep getting shot down. I don’t know if people want to hear it because there is like a people don’t always like to hear the supplement angle for some reason, like a whole food, whole food, whole food. Yeah, but
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 44:23
you at some point, and I was like hands
Dr. David Church 44:25
are tied right now. You know,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 44:27
I was like that too. I for the longest time thought, okay, fine, you can have your omega threes. Don’t worry about vitamin D. You can be out in the sun, which is not realistic with you know. I get it. Yeah, right with kids being inside, whatever it is. And then I was thinking, okay, well, I’m gonna eat enough pomegranate to make a postbiotic called urolithin A. You know, I thought all of these things, and then in real life practice, it doesn’t translate.
Dr. David Church 44:52
Yeah, because the essentials, the essential amino acids.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 44:55
Yeah, why don’t you explain? Teach us about essential.
Dr. David Church 44:57
Yeah, yeah, I have no affiliation with anyone that does anything. Essential amino acids, except Bob has a company that sells them, and Bob was one of my mentors. But I don’t make a dime off it. And I came in and I worked with Jess Gwynn during some of these warfighter studies where I have energy deficits, and they kept being like, “We’re gonna do a bunch of EAZA’s,” and we were kind of like, “I don’t, okay, why not just whey protein?” And I’ve, and it’s it’s not, yeah, no, you’re nailing it. It’s not the same, and it’s one of these things that I’ve I’ve come and sort of seen their point. It’s not for everyone, right? But
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 45:26
what did you find? There was still an aversion because it’s still it’s still too. I don’t know.
Dr. David Church 45:31
I don’t think people have problems. The beauty of them, there’s no like black magic secret of them. It’s just that you’ve already broken it. They’re already broken down. So ingesting requires no digestion. It’s straight into the bloodstream, so it doesn’t fill you up. So that’s the big thing for older adults or anyone that has reduced appetite or is undergoing a purposeful energy deficit. You sort of trick the body on how much protein it’s seeing.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 45:52
Exactly right. That’s exactly why we use it.
Dr. David Church 45:54
Yeah, because there’s a study where Arnie did it after rehab. Individuals got knee arthroplasty, and they gave him 45 grams of essential amino acids, and for the listeners, that’s like 100 grams of whey protein.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 46:06
It’s double, right? Isn’t it? Yes.
Dr. David Church 46:09
Yeah, whey protein is about 44% EAs. Egg whites 44, milks 42%. Right? We were able to get 45 grams of essentials, and which is
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 46:18
equivalent to 100 grams of whey protein,
Dr. David Church 46:21
or I think two eggs has five grams of EA. So do the math, right? It’s a lot of eggs. All
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 46:27
grams of protein. Yeah,
Dr. David Church 46:29
you’re actually tricking the body into seeing a lot of protein, and then again, the calories are low on it, so you’re not taking up. You’re not now. You have true what I like to call supplemental nutrition, not replacement nutrition. If even if you look in the soldiers, Lee Margolis is the lead author on this paper. Also, was at Arium at the time in 20 shoot 2014, I believe they did a Arctic Norway ski training. So tons of calories. They measured the energy balance, and these soldiers were in a 3000 to 3500 kilocalorie deficit. They gave them all their Marines. One group got carbohydrate supplements. One group got protein supplements. The group that got the supplements took it, but for every calorie of the supplement they took, they one less calorie of their food. And in, I mean, that’s not ideal. There, we’d like to meet their food and their supplements, but particularly in our clinical populations, that’s not the goal. We don’t want to replace their food with just a supplement. Right. We want it to be supplemental. And so I, I feel like in that case, by not having as large of an impact on the appetite with the essential amino acids and being digested much more fast or much more quickly, now we can get true supplemental nutrition. And so, like I said, we gave 45 grams of essentials in that study, and they
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 47:32
pretty incredible.
Dr. David Church 47:33
Yeah, and so you can really pump up the sort of the dietary protein the body thinks it’s seeing, and we can still we get playing the benefits. You know, we’ve shown in heart failure patients, aging, rehab. They’ve done in liver fat. It’s reduced the liver fat in patients. I think
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 47:48
that is
Dr. David Church 47:49
what I think is that the EEA requirements are probably higher than we realized. I
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 47:52
was gonna. I’m gonna ask you a really nerdy question. We were talking about the RDA for protein is 0.8 grams per kg, which hasn’t changed. Now they recommend 1.2 to 1.6 grams per kg. That’s the recommendation, right? But they haven’t addressed the essential amino acid or the individual amino acid meats. No,
Dr. David Church 48:10
they have not.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 48:11
And there’s been no discussion on that. And I’m getting you ready for my question. This is my really nerdy questions. We only, for the most part, prioritize muscle meat, and we prioritize muscle meat has a high level of branching amino acids. There’s probably other, you know, like is you know methionine restriction. Do we need more cysteine for glutathione production? The balance of or glycine. Just some of these individual amino acids. That is there a potential that we need more for certain things,
Dr. David Church 48:42
we’re starting to get there. Anna Thalaker Mercer, UAB, she’s shown that glycine and serine help with those satellite cell things we were talking about earlier. So
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 48:50
this is a major nerd moment that we think is interesting. That you know our fellow fellow nerds might think is interesting is that we talk about the essentials. We don’t really break down exactly what you know: threonine for mucin production,
Dr. David Church 49:03
yeah,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 49:04
or cysteine for glutathione production. Right, but we are ingesting the same, pretty much the same ratio for only having, say, muscle meat.
Dr. David Church 49:13
Yeah, it’s pretty interesting because we have a paper and review that I think we’ve hit the final edits on. We’ve tried to model, not tried, we did we did a good job. How much essential amino acids are lost in a day if you don’t feed? We know from some of the you know we stand on the shoulders of giants four hours versus 24 hours. It actually hasn’t changed muscle protein breakdown or whole body protein breakdown.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 49:32
Whole body if someone doesn’t eat any of our bread,
Dr. David Church 49:34
it stays pretty darn consistent. The amount of essentials lost in a day somewhere in the neighborhood of like 384 mgs per kg per day. If you extrapolate that out to a diet, what that means if you have a diet that’s 100% total ill digestibility. What I mean by that is, is once something reaches the ileus, it’s been it’s it’s it’s either digested by by the body or it’s not. So you’ve taken something in that’s 100% total ill digestibility. The amino acids are. Used by the body, so if you have 100% total ileal digestibility diet, and the diet is like 42%, 44% EA, so whey protein, egg whites, that’s it. Then you need 0.88 grams per kilogram a day of dietary protein to meet those EA requirements.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 50:15
Just the minimum requirements to maintain the whole body
Dr. David Church 50:18
on a as ideal of a diet as possible. We probably don’t get 42% EA. We probably get 34%. And where I pull that number from is our feeding trials, where we weigh in and out what people are eating, and we look in the USDA database. Most of our omnivorous diets are 34, 32% essential amino acids by content. The total ill-digestibility of those diets is somewhere about 90%. When you do that, you need like 1.27 grams of dietary protein per kilogram. I mean that’s
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 50:44
a big deal, and
Dr. David Church 50:45
that aligns with the IAO methodology, and that aligns. Which is
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 50:48
too much for this podcast, but Booever number two.
Dr. David Church 50:50
Yeah, yeah, it aligns with another way amino acid oxidation method. So if you just measure how much purely how much of the intake is oxidized, and you back into
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 51:00
technically all of it is oxidized, right?
Dr. David Church 51:02
Actually, we lose a lot of in the gut.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 51:04
In the gut, but meaning everything that we eat is is utilized, oxidized, lost in the use. It’s used for
Dr. David Church 51:10
something. Yeah, we don’t really waste.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 51:13
What I’m saying is that if you eat excess protein, it doesn’t automatically turn into fat adipose tissue.
Dr. David Church 51:19
Yeah, we use. I’ve
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 51:19
heard this from clinicians.
Dr. David Church 51:22
Yeah, we we
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 51:23
very difficult.
Dr. David Church 51:23
Yeah, it’s a very difficult concept. But so that was what was interesting in doing that modeling paper. And in parallel, without communication, Mick Deutsch at Texas A and M, with a slightly different methodology, is doing this was doing sort of the same thing where we were trying to figure out how much amino acids are needed off a isotope method, and he found the exact same amount we did. It does seem like the essential amino acid requirements are higher than like what the FAO or WHO are reporting, and that’s okay. I think we’ll get there. I mean, people are like Raj Longo just published a nice paper recently about methionine requirements. You know, I forget in the population, they looked at requirements for children in like India that have a parasite infection because it’s quite common and
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 51:59
also common in the U.S. right away,
Dr. David Church 52:01
and as you can imagine, they were higher in those populations. So I we are moving there. I know that the combined Canadian U.S. DRI macronutrients are hopefully meeting in the next year or so, and I know that the sort of essential amino acids are they want to take a look at it. And some of us are trying to go that way through different different things. I’m interested in phenylalanine requirements. You are, yeah, yeah, yeah. To see if well because it’s used for dopamine
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 52:26
about that. Because yes, and we tag it. Seems like it’s readily available. I was hoping you were going to say methionine.
Dr. David Church 52:33
I am, but I’m interested.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 52:35
We’re really, really nerding out right now. I
Dr. David Church 52:38
have a great colleague at UMS, Isabel Muse, who does only methionine restriction in animals, and she does it with cancer. And it’s really cool because it helps with the radiation point if you do restriction. But we’ve talked about it doesn’t seem like it’s something that we can translate up the chain. So we’re trying to figure out maybe different strategies.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 52:53
And to translate this for you guys who are listening, I actually had Tracy Anthony.
Dr. David Church 52:56
She’s brilliant
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 52:57
talking about methionine restriction because a vegan diet is technically methionine restriction, and it upregulates a lot of these stressors. And we’re thinking, okay, well, what is the role of methionine restriction, and how does that then translate to the general population? Dr. David Church, you are amazing, so entertaining, and our friend at the Protein Summit are going to take me off with like a hook and a gong,
Dr. David Church 53:21
yeah.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 53:22
Because people are dying to interview you. I hope you come back for number two. And in fact,
Dr. David Church 53:27
yes,
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 53:27
we might even have time on Thursday to to drag you back. Where can people find you?
Dr. David Church 53:32
As long as you’re nice to me, I always try to reply. Like, don’t
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 53:34
you dare give your email on here. I don’t. I do not do the email. The email.
Dr. David Church 53:38
I’ve made that mistake. Do the
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 53:39
phone number.
Dr. David Church 53:39
Instagram. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. One 800. Yeah, no. Instagram at Dr. Milehead is a good place. Twitter, I’ll still post there occasionally. Instagram, Dr. Mohead, and then LinkedIn, just David Church. I try to post there as much.
Dr. Gabrielle Lyon 53:50
Amazing. Thank you so much. Thank you for being back.
Dr. David Church 53:53
Appreciate it. Likewise.














